A great erotic concept, the stranded trope is a tricky one to pull off. A man and a woman fucking on an island gets old fast: the excitement lies in the mounting sexual tension that eventually brings them together. The writing has to be top notch to keep it both interesting and believable. Therefore however enticing the idea is, it's rarely tackled as a porn game and those attempts that were made ended up pretty lacklustre.
Lewd Island is one of the more successful assaults on this fortress, yet still falls quite short of greatness. On the positive side, the incest hook adds a little spice and the game used to generate visuals seems well suited to the genre, allowing for some sexy scenarios. The girl looks pretty enough, even if the abundance of make-up is a little silly given the context.
It's the writing, most crucial for the setting, that brings this game down. While there are a few interesting ideas being thrown around, the tension that should bring the concept to life is just not there. The dialogue is wordy and tedious, emotions are all over the place and rarely make sense, and most damning the writing frequently loses sight of the setting and falls back on tired clichés: suitcases wash ashore filled with sexy outfits, dug up magic potions generate lust and the girl insists on having her first kiss after a romantic diner in a conveniently discovered red cocktail dress. Random endless dream sequences don't help the pacing much either. The sex scenes themselves finally are rare and way too basic to cover for the lack of arousal generated by the writing, if you can find them in the first place as the wrong choice can lock you out if you're not careful.
Still worth a quick playthrough as the initial experience is exciting enough to be enjoyable, but too superficial for a deeper engagement. Three out of five.
Lewd Island is one of the more successful assaults on this fortress, yet still falls quite short of greatness. On the positive side, the incest hook adds a little spice and the game used to generate visuals seems well suited to the genre, allowing for some sexy scenarios. The girl looks pretty enough, even if the abundance of make-up is a little silly given the context.
It's the writing, most crucial for the setting, that brings this game down. While there are a few interesting ideas being thrown around, the tension that should bring the concept to life is just not there. The dialogue is wordy and tedious, emotions are all over the place and rarely make sense, and most damning the writing frequently loses sight of the setting and falls back on tired clichés: suitcases wash ashore filled with sexy outfits, dug up magic potions generate lust and the girl insists on having her first kiss after a romantic diner in a conveniently discovered red cocktail dress. Random endless dream sequences don't help the pacing much either. The sex scenes themselves finally are rare and way too basic to cover for the lack of arousal generated by the writing, if you can find them in the first place as the wrong choice can lock you out if you're not careful.
Still worth a quick playthrough as the initial experience is exciting enough to be enjoyable, but too superficial for a deeper engagement. Three out of five.