This game was a wild ride, easily one of the best I have ever played in terms of story. Let's break it down.
Bad
Now if these following negatives seem a bit nitpicky that's because...they are. This game is damn near flawless and I have to nitpick to find negatives with it. From the story, music, character development, gameplay it's all superb.
Music volume-While I love the music the problem I have with the music in this game is the one I have with pretty much every game. Some is just too fucking loud while others I found myself turning up. The default music while in the Crowley or that annoying song that grew on me and I found myself vibing to whenever you go get some coffee, you know the song, I had to constantly turn up only to get ear blasted every time Molly was introduced. I wish game devs would equalize the volume. I get that sometimes its thematic and necessary to have some songs be louder than others, but there's no reason why Molly's theme should be significantly louder than Jenny's.
Bella-while I love her as a character and her character model is easily my favorite that's where the flaw is. When she's standing next to other characters especially during one scene where she's next to both your Mom, and Emily it makes her look like she's from a different game. She stands out compared to them and not always in a good way. Every single character looks like they are from the same game except for Bella.
Combat-While the combat eventually grew on me it was unbalanced and some of the important fights being literally unlosable really took me out of the immersion. Suddenly that big bad that's going to destroy the world is just some brainless fight that I can mindlessly fight while I throw on some first things first in the background. The change to a poison build in book 3 that nerfed the hell out of it while also making rage builds ridiculously op with Berserk just made zero sense. Book 2 is the most fun combat in the game using Emily, Molly, and Akane on the hardest difficulty was the most fun I had with the game which quickly ends once you hit book 3.
Lack of pixie scenes-There I said. The tease in book 3 had me fuming, as I craved more Snowdrop scenes. Having an army of pixies following you around...damn, unlucky.
End of book 2-It should have ended at the table scene. Had it ended there it would have been 10/10 but instead it gives you one extra little ending that makes the impact and emotional ending of book 2 make you feel like everything is going to be okay, at least that's how I felt. Looking at "you know who" during the table scene then getting "taken" I instantly knew "oh okay everything's fine"
Neutral
Sex scenes-they're mid. That's pretty much it. They eventually get animated but none of them are the quality of some of the other juggernauts in this genre and that's okay imo. You aren't overwhelmed with scenes and sometimes you could have an entire game session without encountering a single one because this game spreads them out and makes it feel real. Personally I love it as I care much more about the story. A lot of the scenes are impactful to the story instead of just being a quick fuck and that makes them 10x better imo. With that said I do understand that not everyone feels the same way which is why Ive opted to place it in the neutral category.
Renders-Much like the previous 2 in this category it's only here because some people may dislike it, because I know I did at first. Once you unlock elsewhere I hope you enjoy the backgrounds because they dont change, you repeat the same areas over and over and over again. Obviously that changes slightly in book 2 the complaint remains the same. While I wasn't a fan at first especially looking at one of the characters compared to the background it grew on me. I mean look how big this fucking game is and he managed to complete it in only a few years. I know nothing about game dev but I can promise you that using the same backgrounds over and over had to of saved him hundreds of hours of dev time. I've seen game devs who make more money with a game half as big not even come close to being anywhere near as complete as this game, and I can only assume part of it is due to reusing the same areas over and over again.
Linear story-Some are gonna love it some are gonna hate it. While I prefer choices I've only ever played one game on this site that does it correct. Most others that attempt it end up fizzling out because as it turns out keeping multiple different branching paths that most of the player base wont see is not worth the time nor effort. Now this one is VERY linear with very little choices that amount to nothing and that's okay, Droid set out to tell a story his way and he does most spectacularly. Much like the sex scenes it's only here because some people might find issue with it even though I don't.
Companion combat-Once again the combat balance is pretty bad. Certain companions are just awful and there's no reason to ever bring them but I find that to be okay. Once I found my favorites I had a good time. And while there is the occasionally "okay Ill bring along Y for this big battle" theres few of those and you tend to just use the same from book to book.
Book 3-Listen I love book 3 as much as the next guy but lets be honest. By the time it hits we already know everything. The MC is probably the most powerful person in existence, nothing feels like a threat anymore. You bitch around gods, smite demons and outsiders, the threat feels more like nuisance which is exactly how MC treats it which I do kinda like. Your companions feels less valuable in combat as you tend to hit harder, no longer are they the carries instead of you. And while I do love how Droid managed to hit that feeling of you being OP as fuck, it did leave me yearning for the feeling of the earlier books. It was inevitable and it was handled as good as possible but that doesn't mean that I have to love that feeling and I don't. I miss the grind.
Good
Anything that I didnt mention pretty much belongs here but heres a few that stand out.
Droid himself-Most importantly is this. At the time of writing this he's still active and the games been completed for a little bit. He's answered a few of my questions himself and he interacts with the fans of his games, I love these kinds of devs. When I ended up subbing to his patreon he sent me a message thanking me and offering to send me steam keys to both LoM and Morningstar. What more could you ask for form a dev?
Writing-It's amazing. I tend to put the game devs into tiers when it comes to their writing. Tier 0 is reserved for one writer who is a legit author and is easily the best Ive seen end of story. So the other great writers end up in Tier 1-2. Tier 1 is reserved for the greats and while all their styles are different they all belong in tier 1 and we know who a lot of those writers are, and I genuinely believe that Droid belongs in that tier. While maybe not at the top of the tier I can easily place him in it as he's better than any of the writers I have in tier 2.
Music-Yeah yeah I know, I had it in the "Bad" category but the actual music is fantastic. This game might have the best soundtrack I've played. Even Molly's theme which annoyed me at first grew on me as I found myself smiling and nodding everytime her face popped up on my screen. Jenny's theme is another that I grew to love. Also special shoutout to the email. X is right that song is a banger.
Story-It's great and has an actual ending. A lot of these games even the "completed" ones have endings that either leave a lot of questions or feel unsatisfying. And while yes this ending does leave you wanting a sequel it's more than satisfying. And I feel that some of those questions will be answered in Morningstar.
The story is fantastic though. From start to finish I was constantly looking forward to more of the game, to unraveling the riddles, and twists of the game. The impactful moments FELT impactful, instead of being told I should be sad I actually was. Honestly my biggest gripe was the end of book 2.
World building-Yep, it's pretty damn good. Granted there wasn't "that much" since it's based on our world but with magic. It's urban fantasy, and like with most urban fantasy there's significantly less world building than say full blow fantasy, and that's okay. Because the world building there is, is fantastic. Especially once elsewhere opens up or once book 2 starts.
Gameplay-The gameplay meme of these kinds of games is legit "left click" and while that's true mostly in Book 1, Book 2 changes that. I went from feeling like I was playing "generic f95 game" to fucking Pathfinder and it was welcome.
Characters-This is the last part of the review and they deserve to be the topic that wraps up the review as they are phenomenal. I could do an entire review alone just talking about the characters. Each of of them is unique, which is hard to for most devs honestly even in triple A games, just look at Starfield while I love the game all the main human companions are the same with the same views and feel similar. This game however each one feels different and they don't just grow on you they grow on each other and the MC. Molly for instance is my favorite and I went through multiple feeling for her. From thinking she was a cunt, to finding her catty and funny, to obsessive and annoying and wishing she was back to her old self, to actually loving her and appreciating her being the "older sister" of the group and helping out my marriage to becoming my favorite character in the game. Every single character in this game goes through a massive character arch and I love it. Emily, Katie, Jenny, Chloe (to a lesser degree), Bella, Akane, Dylan, Draco, Foxy, etc they all grow as people (and dragons) and the game is better for each one of them. There isn't a single character that the game would be better without. There isn't a single companion that I dislike even a bit.
Now obviously I probably missed some Bad, Neutral, and God that I would have loved to include but when a game this big takes you over a month to complete you're gonna forget some stuff. But with that said the game is an easy 5/5 not even rounding up. It's amazing. It's left a LoM size hole in my heart that's made the next few games after it feel dull, something which hasn't happened to me since I finished Enderal a few years ago. Part of me wishes I could erase the game from my memory so I could give it another go while the other part looks forward to the day Morninstar finishes.
If you enjoy story focuses games then this game is a MUST play. If you're someone who only cares about sex scenes then you should probably skip it, and if you're someone in between who values both then give it a go because if you value story at all it will pull you in. This game has entered my top 5 of all time on this site. My only regret is that I skipped past it so many times to play other games and didn't play it sooner because as far as this genre of games go it is a master piece.
Bad
Now if these following negatives seem a bit nitpicky that's because...they are. This game is damn near flawless and I have to nitpick to find negatives with it. From the story, music, character development, gameplay it's all superb.
Music volume-While I love the music the problem I have with the music in this game is the one I have with pretty much every game. Some is just too fucking loud while others I found myself turning up. The default music while in the Crowley or that annoying song that grew on me and I found myself vibing to whenever you go get some coffee, you know the song, I had to constantly turn up only to get ear blasted every time Molly was introduced. I wish game devs would equalize the volume. I get that sometimes its thematic and necessary to have some songs be louder than others, but there's no reason why Molly's theme should be significantly louder than Jenny's.
Bella-while I love her as a character and her character model is easily my favorite that's where the flaw is. When she's standing next to other characters especially during one scene where she's next to both your Mom, and Emily it makes her look like she's from a different game. She stands out compared to them and not always in a good way. Every single character looks like they are from the same game except for Bella.
Combat-While the combat eventually grew on me it was unbalanced and some of the important fights being literally unlosable really took me out of the immersion. Suddenly that big bad that's going to destroy the world is just some brainless fight that I can mindlessly fight while I throw on some first things first in the background. The change to a poison build in book 3 that nerfed the hell out of it while also making rage builds ridiculously op with Berserk just made zero sense. Book 2 is the most fun combat in the game using Emily, Molly, and Akane on the hardest difficulty was the most fun I had with the game which quickly ends once you hit book 3.
Lack of pixie scenes-There I said. The tease in book 3 had me fuming, as I craved more Snowdrop scenes. Having an army of pixies following you around...damn, unlucky.
End of book 2-It should have ended at the table scene. Had it ended there it would have been 10/10 but instead it gives you one extra little ending that makes the impact and emotional ending of book 2 make you feel like everything is going to be okay, at least that's how I felt. Looking at "you know who" during the table scene then getting "taken" I instantly knew "oh okay everything's fine"
Neutral
Sex scenes-they're mid. That's pretty much it. They eventually get animated but none of them are the quality of some of the other juggernauts in this genre and that's okay imo. You aren't overwhelmed with scenes and sometimes you could have an entire game session without encountering a single one because this game spreads them out and makes it feel real. Personally I love it as I care much more about the story. A lot of the scenes are impactful to the story instead of just being a quick fuck and that makes them 10x better imo. With that said I do understand that not everyone feels the same way which is why Ive opted to place it in the neutral category.
Renders-Much like the previous 2 in this category it's only here because some people may dislike it, because I know I did at first. Once you unlock elsewhere I hope you enjoy the backgrounds because they dont change, you repeat the same areas over and over and over again. Obviously that changes slightly in book 2 the complaint remains the same. While I wasn't a fan at first especially looking at one of the characters compared to the background it grew on me. I mean look how big this fucking game is and he managed to complete it in only a few years. I know nothing about game dev but I can promise you that using the same backgrounds over and over had to of saved him hundreds of hours of dev time. I've seen game devs who make more money with a game half as big not even come close to being anywhere near as complete as this game, and I can only assume part of it is due to reusing the same areas over and over again.
Linear story-Some are gonna love it some are gonna hate it. While I prefer choices I've only ever played one game on this site that does it correct. Most others that attempt it end up fizzling out because as it turns out keeping multiple different branching paths that most of the player base wont see is not worth the time nor effort. Now this one is VERY linear with very little choices that amount to nothing and that's okay, Droid set out to tell a story his way and he does most spectacularly. Much like the sex scenes it's only here because some people might find issue with it even though I don't.
Companion combat-Once again the combat balance is pretty bad. Certain companions are just awful and there's no reason to ever bring them but I find that to be okay. Once I found my favorites I had a good time. And while there is the occasionally "okay Ill bring along Y for this big battle" theres few of those and you tend to just use the same from book to book.
Book 3-Listen I love book 3 as much as the next guy but lets be honest. By the time it hits we already know everything. The MC is probably the most powerful person in existence, nothing feels like a threat anymore. You bitch around gods, smite demons and outsiders, the threat feels more like nuisance which is exactly how MC treats it which I do kinda like. Your companions feels less valuable in combat as you tend to hit harder, no longer are they the carries instead of you. And while I do love how Droid managed to hit that feeling of you being OP as fuck, it did leave me yearning for the feeling of the earlier books. It was inevitable and it was handled as good as possible but that doesn't mean that I have to love that feeling and I don't. I miss the grind.
Good
Anything that I didnt mention pretty much belongs here but heres a few that stand out.
Droid himself-Most importantly is this. At the time of writing this he's still active and the games been completed for a little bit. He's answered a few of my questions himself and he interacts with the fans of his games, I love these kinds of devs. When I ended up subbing to his patreon he sent me a message thanking me and offering to send me steam keys to both LoM and Morningstar. What more could you ask for form a dev?
Writing-It's amazing. I tend to put the game devs into tiers when it comes to their writing. Tier 0 is reserved for one writer who is a legit author and is easily the best Ive seen end of story. So the other great writers end up in Tier 1-2. Tier 1 is reserved for the greats and while all their styles are different they all belong in tier 1 and we know who a lot of those writers are, and I genuinely believe that Droid belongs in that tier. While maybe not at the top of the tier I can easily place him in it as he's better than any of the writers I have in tier 2.
Music-Yeah yeah I know, I had it in the "Bad" category but the actual music is fantastic. This game might have the best soundtrack I've played. Even Molly's theme which annoyed me at first grew on me as I found myself smiling and nodding everytime her face popped up on my screen. Jenny's theme is another that I grew to love. Also special shoutout to the email. X is right that song is a banger.
Story-It's great and has an actual ending. A lot of these games even the "completed" ones have endings that either leave a lot of questions or feel unsatisfying. And while yes this ending does leave you wanting a sequel it's more than satisfying. And I feel that some of those questions will be answered in Morningstar.
The story is fantastic though. From start to finish I was constantly looking forward to more of the game, to unraveling the riddles, and twists of the game. The impactful moments FELT impactful, instead of being told I should be sad I actually was. Honestly my biggest gripe was the end of book 2.
World building-Yep, it's pretty damn good. Granted there wasn't "that much" since it's based on our world but with magic. It's urban fantasy, and like with most urban fantasy there's significantly less world building than say full blow fantasy, and that's okay. Because the world building there is, is fantastic. Especially once elsewhere opens up or once book 2 starts.
Gameplay-The gameplay meme of these kinds of games is legit "left click" and while that's true mostly in Book 1, Book 2 changes that. I went from feeling like I was playing "generic f95 game" to fucking Pathfinder and it was welcome.
Characters-This is the last part of the review and they deserve to be the topic that wraps up the review as they are phenomenal. I could do an entire review alone just talking about the characters. Each of of them is unique, which is hard to for most devs honestly even in triple A games, just look at Starfield while I love the game all the main human companions are the same with the same views and feel similar. This game however each one feels different and they don't just grow on you they grow on each other and the MC. Molly for instance is my favorite and I went through multiple feeling for her. From thinking she was a cunt, to finding her catty and funny, to obsessive and annoying and wishing she was back to her old self, to actually loving her and appreciating her being the "older sister" of the group and helping out my marriage to becoming my favorite character in the game. Every single character in this game goes through a massive character arch and I love it. Emily, Katie, Jenny, Chloe (to a lesser degree), Bella, Akane, Dylan, Draco, Foxy, etc they all grow as people (and dragons) and the game is better for each one of them. There isn't a single character that the game would be better without. There isn't a single companion that I dislike even a bit.
Now obviously I probably missed some Bad, Neutral, and God that I would have loved to include but when a game this big takes you over a month to complete you're gonna forget some stuff. But with that said the game is an easy 5/5 not even rounding up. It's amazing. It's left a LoM size hole in my heart that's made the next few games after it feel dull, something which hasn't happened to me since I finished Enderal a few years ago. Part of me wishes I could erase the game from my memory so I could give it another go while the other part looks forward to the day Morninstar finishes.
If you enjoy story focuses games then this game is a MUST play. If you're someone who only cares about sex scenes then you should probably skip it, and if you're someone in between who values both then give it a go because if you value story at all it will pull you in. This game has entered my top 5 of all time on this site. My only regret is that I skipped past it so many times to play other games and didn't play it sooner because as far as this genre of games go it is a master piece.