Blender vs Daz3D: What's Best for You?

Sep 4, 2020
91
47
is still actively ? (As recently as 50 min ago).

"This release will probably be the final one when it comes to new features. Version 1.0 of the DAZ Importer was released in 2016, but I looked into importing native DAZ files as early as 2011, so the add-on is already ten years old. It has grown into a much more ambitious project than I ever expected, and is quite enough for my own needs. I will continue to fix bugs and adapt the code to new releases of Blender and DAZ Studio, though."

So not dead, but shifting into a maintenance mode. For the time being, I suppose. I made it sound like it was abandoned, and that was not what I intended.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tdree
Sep 4, 2020
91
47
Can you tell me more about this step?
Sure thing. Basically, I looked over several videos on Youtube about creating skin materials. With Daz you get the mesh, the UV projections, and multiple textures -- the specific ones might depend on the model, but in general you get the diffuse, the bump map, the normal map, a specular map, and a subsurface scattering map. Here's the node setup I use:

1640819702711.png

The subsurface scattering isn't being used, that's not a mistake. It seems to look fine with the diffuse used in both channels.

For hair, I've had good results dumping the Diffeo created shader setup for a simple Principled Hair BSDF using the melanin mode. The principled hair bsdf does things like subsurface scattering and such -- the hair looks much more interesting as a result. It catches the light, has nice shiny spots, things like that.

I have to say that the setup looks ridiculously simple. I might add a color ramp here or there to see if I can affect the skin in interesting ways, but for naughty VN renders, you don't need to go crazy. Really, the trick is good lighting.

One problem I do have with the Daz setup is the UV maps. The body map and the face map are the same size even though a face is much less skin than a whole torso. That means the face texture is very nicely detailed, but the same bumps and freckles on the body look smeared out. That's because the same size image is being stretched over a much larger body map.

Here's a closeup. To the left is the lower jaw and the right is the neck. At the boundary you can really see the difference in the quality.

1640820169937.png

Not sure what I can do about this. As long as I don't zoom in, I suppose it'll be ok. A touch of post-processing would help too. I might also look through my assets to see if there is a model with a larger torso texture sized to match the UV map.

Or maybe find a properly sized set of textures and re-map the UVs to that. I have a set that might work, but sheesh, the trouble in redoing the UVs!
 
Last edited:

Deleted member 1121028

Well-Known Member
Dec 28, 2018
1,716
3,292
"This release will probably be the final one when it comes to new features. Version 1.0 of the DAZ Importer was released in 2016, but I looked into importing native DAZ files as early as 2011, so the add-on is already ten years old. It has grown into a much more ambitious project than I ever expected, and is quite enough for my own needs. I will continue to fix bugs and adapt the code to new releases of Blender and DAZ Studio, though."

So not dead, but shifting into a maintenance mode. For the time being, I suppose. I made it sound like it was abandoned, and that was not what I intended.
Oh well seems you're right.

I'm curious what do need more in term of material tho.

It seems extremely subpar tho :

1592519_1640819702711.png
 
Sep 4, 2020
91
47
Oh well seems you're right.

I'm curious what do need more in term of material tho.

It seems extremely subpar tho :

View attachment 1569902
It looks pretty sparse, I know. But the result was quite nice. But as I said in another response, I'm probably not finished. I'll keep messing with it, if just to learn how to do shaders better.

Ignore the eyes. Clearly the character got into the Dune Spice supply I keep in my desk for when I need to navigate to the grocery store. Also this is a working model, stripped of subdivs and other modifiers. Curves, like the tops of the ears, look blocky as a result. Currently, I'm playing with multi-res so that I can sculpt in some extra details.

1640820473639.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: Baka plays