- May 5, 2022
- 63
- 43
I mean, the math has always been somewhat hinky for me with Shannon and Frank being 39, Rebecca being 23. This means Shannon was around 16 when Becca was born, 15 when Becca was concieved, probably with about a years leeway on either side. So she was most likely concieved while Frank and Shannon were together in high school. We know that they were together 6 months and Frank and Jess Graduated that year or the following(not sure it is specifically mentioned).At least some of the Becca truthers have some ammo since she referred to her bio dad as only Lily's dad... to complete strangers whom she just met.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
It could mean something or it could mean nothing. It could mean that Becca has an inkling that Shannon at a minimum was dishonest regarding Becca's paternity. It doesn't necessarily mean that Frank was the father, but it may explain why Lily's dad didn't hand around (you know, other than just him being an asshole). It is just as likely that she refuses to name him as a father for the reasons that she has already stated, having buried that relationship long ago.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
All this is just for fun, though. I'm not trying to start another flame war... honest...
That being said considering how Shannon was and is, and Frank pushing her to be less antagonistic with Jess, it would not surprise me if she had slept around to 'get even' with Frank for his audacity/lack of loyalty or something.
This has always stuck out to me, but having replayed the game recently from the beginning, it is more on my mind now.
Some of this might just be the result of plot changes, with the previous chapters not being fully/completely changed to reflect that. Like when Frank first mentions the Gym in his thoughts he remembers it being pretty decent, then when he actually gets around to visiting it in the stuff, apparently it now had always been a bit of a dump in the past.
EDIT: Leaving this here for future additions after I dive back into the game to verify some math.
Additional Hinkiness Edit: When we see the flashback Frank says he was 16 when they moved and the text says it was 25 years ago. But With Frank turning 40, he would have to be turning 15 that year, or abouts
As someone else posted while I was typing this, Becca emotional investment and imprinting on Frank could be responsible for her phrasing.
Last edited: