- May 25, 2017
- 2,780
- 4,907
[POLL] Male or Futa(dickgirl) MC preference?
- Thread starter AfroM
- Start date
- Jul 29, 2017
- 6,834
- 83,127
..also not many votes.....this time....
So think about it from the perspective of a male viewing porn:
- Male on Male is 100% gay.
- Male on Female is 50% gay because there's a guy in the porn.
- Female on Female is 0% gay, but we lose out on a lot of sex positions and there's no penile ejaculation.
So Futa on Female would be around 10-15% gay, while having just as many sex positions as Male on Female does.
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
Ah, I see, well you have a point, but I also need a female perspective to some reactions and such, but when the fem MC gets the male lower genitalia so now has a bit more testosterone so might be able to camouflage it a bit whit whit some general male replays, but on the sex parts whit the female MC will be girl on girl lewd scenes
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
Quite~ yet I make the poll on many different places and on those the dickgirl won x) not to worry when I finish the prologue whit the dickgirl I will make one whit the male counterpart fair is fair x)
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
Yeah, was thinking if I lesf the poll a few days more the might have been balanced, was 50% most of the time x)
If you don't plan to or can't think of a way to meaningfully differentiate them then it's better to leave the option off. I've seen a few recently that took this so far that the characters didn't even acknowledge the 'futa version' of the MC; the only difference was what art was used in the sex scenes.
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
Oh, hmm I think I know what you mean, I think at least, the thing is whit the illusion engine it's a bit hard to make a bulge in general apart from a especial underwear that remark a bulge for the "Futa" so I kind of planning to make the MC mail clothes to wear the front unzipped jeans showing the bulge so it's obvious she is a dickgirl and the other characters can see it and know themselves, the MC might even state it to the family a few times or those close to her
- May 25, 2017
- 2,780
- 4,907
Wait are you using HS, or KK? Because the KK better repack has an actual "bulge" slider mod included. HS might have a mod for one, too.
I mean it more in the narrative sense. If you can't even be bothered to rewrite the scenes enough to where they acknowledge that the futa version of the MC is not a man, something I've seen in a couple of recent games, then it doesn't feel like an actual character - just a contrivance to get as many boobs on screen as possible.
It's a problem a lot of these games have. As a for instance I tried Roundscape Adorevia recently and the first scene I ran into was one where the cleric party member girl is nervous about sharing a room with the main character. It makes sense for a male MC but not really for a female MC; the accompanying creeper scene you can get also doesn't come off as something a female character would do. If you're going to have different options for the MC's gender then the writing should treat them differently enough to where the scenes you envision make sense. That's why it's best to write what you know; no gender option is better than one that feels forced and half-assed.
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
I'm using HS or well specifically AI syoujyo but same models, not sure about the bulge, can do some research I guess
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
well that is a blast from the past, havent heard or played that game in a while, but yeah i get what you mean, that is why im careful enough to have separate scripts for each mc where for the male i would put myself in the situation and how i would react for example, like a male, and then i ask a few female friends how they wouldreact and add them to the story, like for example the MC has a twin sister, if its male, they would have at the begining like a bit of privacy in their shared room ( they are low class citizens so not alot of money) so have something like a small courtain or slider in the middle of the room so each have their space, but if they are both girls (at least the fem mc at the start) they woudnt need the curtain or separator since they would both be girls and wouldnt mind seeing each other naked or in their underwear, but later after the fem MC gains the male genitalia she slightly start to feel a bit embarrased that her sister sees her naked now or just tries to brush it off or tries to act whit a bit more privacy, stuff like that, like remarking that she now has something out of the normal standart that wasnt there before, stuff like that, but i acknoledge the changes in the story, since its a bit of a story driven corruption game where things slowly change its a given to acknoledge each changes that happends in the story, or at least my idea is to make each change in the characters count, like if the sister had a normal body and now suddenly after X event she has a shortstack body tipe and is shorter, she would complain about her height and that barely any clothes fit her, stuff like that.
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
as far as my search go i cant find any bulge mods x)
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
not to worry, the male MC will be added as well once im done whit Selene ( fem MC default name) once the prologue whit her is done ill post it and start doing the prologue for the male MC
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
i tried using a few male pants that showed bulge but sadly cant find the way to have the male pants on a female character x)
- May 25, 2017
- 2,780
- 4,907
Yeah, AI Shoujo seems to have a lack of mods, compared to HS and especially KK. As far as I know, KK is the only one with a mod that lets you use any clothes you want on any character
- Dec 26, 2017
- 120
- 115
yeah, have been noticing, the quality is a bit better on shoujo so i mainly used that one, but im dowloading HS just in case to see which one is a bit better, im the quality of the characters vary a bit between episodes it might mostl be because im deciding which one to useYeah, AI Shoujo seems to have a lack of mods, compared to HS and especially KK. As far as I know, KK is the only one with a mod that lets you use any clothes you want on any character