I've only played Karryn's Prison (Loved it btw) and I've only just started to play Melty's Quest so I can't give an opinion yet, but I do want hear your thoughts.
In your opinion, which game is better and why? Karryn's Prison or Melty's Quest?
- Thread starter LaneGofu
- Start date
Karryn's Prison has alot of it's own issues, but it wins by a long shot. There's just too much grind in Melty's.
I played Melty quest once a long time ago and i think i remember that the combat system was pretty meh.
It was just a standard linear corruption game with little to no forced content. So Karryn's prison is way better in the sense that it add an original combat system + a lot of replayability option + sexual content even if you don't play the character as a slut (aka forced content)
The only good thing in Melty quest was the costume system, but it was very standard too since it was locked behing lewdness lvl or something like that. It wasn't a very ambitious game.
It was just a standard linear corruption game with little to no forced content. So Karryn's prison is way better in the sense that it add an original combat system + a lot of replayability option + sexual content even if you don't play the character as a slut (aka forced content)
The only good thing in Melty quest was the costume system, but it was very standard too since it was locked behing lewdness lvl or something like that. It wasn't a very ambitious game.
- May 10, 2017
- 817
- 1,943
Melty's Quest is the best of the JRPG's I have played, great character designs, decent story, only decent example of the win to see scenes gameplay.
I was looking forward to Karryn's Prison a lot, but I ended up being extremely disappointed. I appear to be in the minority in my dislike of the game. Karryn looks amazing, the scenes look amazing and I have to give credit it the detail and effort behind combining gameplay with the sex scenes.
But the game has no real story to speak of, the only character I remember other than Karryn was the fat Orc and worst of all, the sexual element is turned into a mind numbing chore, that is not a good thing in a sex game.
I was looking forward to Karryn's Prison a lot, but I ended up being extremely disappointed. I appear to be in the minority in my dislike of the game. Karryn looks amazing, the scenes look amazing and I have to give credit it the detail and effort behind combining gameplay with the sex scenes.
But the game has no real story to speak of, the only character I remember other than Karryn was the fat Orc and worst of all, the sexual element is turned into a mind numbing chore, that is not a good thing in a sex game.
- Aug 16, 2018
- 153
- 220
I liked the wholesomely lewd protagonist in Meltys' quest. Also it has pregnancy content in the base game without mods.
Only played karryns prison before and I don't quite like it. I stuck at the mid game not knowing how to move forward. There is no story, and zero character design of karryn. I like the battle/sex at the very beginning of the game but my interests decreases quickly.
- Nov 3, 2017
- 7,785
- 6,584
- Jun 25, 2018
- 301
- 407
I played both and will give the slight edge to Karryn's Prison only because I actually went back to it like a porno to scratch an itch, but I think Melty's Quest was the superior game. The reason for this is I felt MQ was complete, whereas KP had so much potential wasted. It started out strong but each update held little additional quality in the side content, nor depth to really keep it going. There was a nurses room that I don't remember if it ever got used once. The library, teaching room and store all had massive potential for side content that got nothing.