How can one who dislikes NTR, who also has three women loyal to them, enjoy a game with brothels, strip clubs, gloryholes & sex clubs?

[hakarlman]

Nope, got no issue with her stripping or camwhoring , but it wouldn't be incredibly erotic, just a way to make money.

I appreciate your honesty. If you think of anything in the future, of how a strip club could be used in some erotic way with your girlfriend, in a non-ntr fashion, PLEASE let me know.

That sounds like a great setup for NTR, where someone somehow manages to identify ur girl and blackmails her, but for non-ntr purposes it sounds like a convoluted way to get a sort of harem.

Anyway looking forward to more of ur polls and threads.

The game is heavily into Netori. Your idea will fit perfectly. That's gold man, GOLD! I'll make it so the MC identifies the girl and blackmails her, but it turns out she's married... oh and she has a daughter, then things get interesting. A scene like this is already in the script, but it doesn't have a strong introduction. Your idea of blackmail makes for the perfect introduction to the scenario. I'm so glad I made this thread.

 

[KingWeWuz]

Well said. I actually have that question in my checklist and apply it to every sex scenario. Asking that simple question has helped me make alternative time efficient solutions to make an erotic experience for the non-ntr guy.



Is there any possible scenario you can think of where your girlfriend dancing at a strip club would be incredibly erotic to you? Be brutally honest, is there any angle you can think of?

Oh, I know. How about this?

[Non-NTR] You own a strip club, but you use it to record erotic videos of your girlfriend dancing then sell it online for money. However, you don't want anyone to know who she is, so you censor her face in the video. Now you can use the strip club as a kind of photo shoot set for creating sexual content. You get a nice dance from her and can make money too. This then escalates into turning the strip club into a porn studio, where you're the star, but you make sure no one can see your girlfriends face. Sound good? Then you bring other girls to the strip club (now a photoshoot set), so you can make more videos and more content.

OK, I'll be honest. I'm pretty damn possessive. You're talking to a member of the fringe faction. Probably one of the more extreme ones. I actually dropped a game I really enjoyed over what I considered lesbian ntr (something only a small fraction of us believe in.) Anyway...

I would find the dance itself hot. And the porn scenes themselves hot. But the selling it for cash wouldn't be erotic for me.

Basically:
->The fact that I'm fucking her on cam (HOT)
->The fact that she's willing to do sexual favors for me on cam (dancing, stripping, etc) (HOT)
->Showing the vids of my girlfriend (with a censor) (dislike, but willing to tolerate)

For the most part the censor does make it more tolerable than uncensored, and I'd still be willing to tolerate both. In other words, since it's not a dealbreaker for me, chances are this would be something most would be ok with and you probably wouldn't get comments like "shit/5 ntr dont download."

As far as an any situation example? Basically if the club was closed, no one but me was there, and she danced on the pole for me personally. Probably not the answer you want, and probably not the answer you'd enjoy basing much of the game off of. That's the only situation I came up with when I read that.

Original vision is intact. I've actually found many creative ways to re-use existing scenarios & poses, so if one scene contains something non-NTR doesn't like, I can morph that scene into something they do like; which is very, very efficient time cost wise.

I'm just saying, while alot of the things you're thinking about doing isn't even ntr (if I pimp out my girlfriend willingly it's not really ntr) but the anti-ntr crowd, myself included, don't' enjoy sharing because we're very possessive.

 

[hakarlman]

OK, I'll be honest. I'm pretty damn possessive. You're talking to a member of the fringe faction. Probably one of the more extreme ones. I actually dropped a game I really enjoyed over what I considered lesbian ntr (something only a small fraction of us believe in.) Anyway...

I would find the dance itself hot. And the porn scenes themselves hot. But the selling it for cash wouldn't be erotic for me.

Basically:
->The fact that I'm fucking her on cam (HOT)
->The fact that she's willing to do sexual favors for me on cam (dancing, stripping, etc) (HOT)

I appreciate your honesty, this helps me out a lot.

->Showing the vids of my girlfriend (with a censor) (dislike, but willing to tolerate)

I just threw that in there to see if you'd be into it (trying to corrupt you lol). I'll make it so it's optional, so you don't make any recordings unless it's just for yourself only.

For the most part the censor does make it more tolerable than uncensored, and I'd still be willing to tolerate both. In other words, since it's not a dealbreaker for me, chances are this would be something most would be ok with and you probably wouldn't get comments like "shit/5 ntr dont download."

I'm trying to avoid non-ntr having to tolerate something. Tolerating is a turn off, so that's a no no. I want it to be an insanely erotic experience that's constant.

Okay, so the goal is to have some hot scenes of the MC's gf stripping in a strip club.

As far as an any situation example? Basically if the club was closed, no one but me was there, and she danced on the pole for me personally. Probably not the answer you want, and probably not the answer you'd enjoy basing much of the game off of. That's the only situation I came up with when I read that.

Believe it or not, I was JUST thinking of your idea. The club can just remained closed and you use it as a private studio for your own pleasure. You can also use it to impress women and bring them there. In the NTR route, women will already come there, so it fits perfectly.

But, I need a way the MC can make money in the game that's sexual. I don't want the player to just click a button: [work] then just get $500.00, that's stupid. There has to be a sexual way to make money. Can you think of anything?

EDIT: Okay I figured it out. I found out a clever way you can make money in the strip club.. LOL it's perfect. I can't share the idea though, better it's a surprise. It has zero NTR of any kind, zero zip nada.

I'm just saying, while alot of the things you're thinking about doing isn't even ntr (if I pimp out my girlfriend willingly it's not really ntr) but the anti-ntr crowd, myself included, don't' enjoy sharing because we're very possessive.

I'm glad your honest. This helps a lot. I'm trying to avoid a situation where non-ntr players have to tolerate a sex scenario they don't like. I already go to great lengths to never force anything sexual without the players consent; adding clear warnings & advice from the NPC's on how to avoid bad things (ntr).

 

[KingWeWuz]

EDIT: Okay I figured it out. I found out a clever way you can make money in the strip club.. LOL it's perfect. I can't share the idea though, better it's a surprise. It has zero NTR of any kind, zero zip nada.

I have this bizarre feeling you're planning to make it a male strip club where the mc will get women to oggle him and give him cash. These terms are acceptable if we don't have to interact with our fellow male strippers.

 

[hakarlman]

I have this bizarre feeling you're planning to make it a male strip club where the mc will get women to oggle him and give him cash. These terms are acceptable if we don't have to interact with our fellow male strippers.

Actually it's not, but I'm glad you brought this up. I thought about adding this route, but I don't know how to perceive a male stripper accurately. Is the male stripper in a position of power, or are the women in the position of power dictating what he does with the power of money?

Here's what I had planned: MC's mother comes to the strip club............................................ She sees her son dancing .............. Does she end up with his hard cock in her mouth while sitting in a chair, while he's sitting on top of the stripper platform? Meanwhile, another women there recognizes her from church, "....but..but... isn't that her son?!...ohhhhh.......She's.... wrapped her lips around his.... oh my ....."

These terms are acceptable if we don't have to interact with our fellow male strippers.

But one of your buddies works there too. When you're at his house, his mother offers you and him special lessons that involve her sucking both of your dicks at the same time; FOR a very good reason I cannot say. So anyways, later that night, you guys are working at the male strip club and his mom comes to visit. She ends up sucking you both off while she's sitting in front of the stripper platform and you two on your knees elevated above her a bit with your big dicks sticking out. His mom his just slobbering on them both to the music, my god. Wait, does this lead to INCEST STRIP CLUB NIGHT? MY DUDE, let go of your possessive nature, lol. Fun aside, I could easily make it so his mom is yours alone. She comes to the club only and either:

a) sucks your dick, and your friend knows she sucks your dick, but there's nothing he can do cuz you're in a position of power over him
b) you do it behind his back

 

[Lerd0]

Actually it's not, but I'm glad you brought this up. I thought about adding this route, but I don't know how to perceive a male stripper accurately. Is the male stripper in a position of power, or are the women in the position of power dictating what he does with the power of money?

The clients tend to think they're in a position of power but the stripper is usually just allowing them to think that they are.

 

[paust.alex]

But, I need a way the MC can make money in the game that's sexual. I don't want the player to just click a button: [work] then just get $500.00, that's stupid. There has to be a sexual way to make money. Can you think of anything?

I can advise you something, I myself plan to use this idea somehow. A restaurant with a "natural" sauce. Imagine, a customer comes in and orders a steak or some rolls. He sits down in his place in front of the reinforced glass, behind which he will be waiting for the order and the girl or boy who will have to give his dish the final shape. The girl squats over a plate of food and begins to masturbate, using only her hand or a toys (girls which can squirt will cost higher), plentifully watering the order with her juices. At this time, the customer can also do whatever he wants, because no one will see him or her, and then he will receive his order with natural sauce. Boy will jerk off and pour the order with sperm.

 

[Lerd0]

I can advise you something, I myself plan to use this idea somehow. A restaurant with a "natural" sauce. Imagine, a customer comes in and orders a steak or some rolls. He sits down in his place in front of the reinforced glass, behind which he will be waiting for the order and the girl or boy who will have to give his dish the final shape. The girl squats over a plate of food and begins to masturbate, using only her hand or a toys (girls which can squirt will cost higher), plentifully watering the order with her juices. At this time, the customer can also do whatever he wants, because no one will see him or her, and then he will receive his order with natural sauce. Boy will jerk off and pour the order with sperm.

That sounds like a lot of healthcode violations.

 

[paust.alex]

That sounds like a lot of healthcode violations.

Just like any brothel.

 

[Lerd0]

Just like any brothel.

Gonna be a bit of a cunt, but don't restaurants and brothels have different guidelines.

 

[Laikhent]

Guys, if you don't mind, I need to know if NTR haters would consider the following NTR:

• You and your girlfriend are in a fight.
• You raise your girlfriends top to reveal her breasts. (an optional tactic)
• The two enemies drop their guard and begin to fondle their crotch (it doesn't actually show this), because they're in awe of your gf's breasts.
• Because they're distracted, you easily knock one enemy out in the next turn.
• Your girlfriend easily knocks out the other.
• You're victorious.

So, in order to win, the MC chose to show his girlfriends incredible breasts to distract the enemy (wow, a tactile genius). The enemies didn't touch her. Would you guys consider this NTR?

By definition I think it would not be NTR, but I would never use that tatic.

[Non-NTR] You own a strip club, but you use it to record erotic videos of your girlfriend dancing then sell it online for money. However, you don't want anyone to know who she is, so you censor her face in the video. Now you can use the strip club as a kind of photo shoot set for creating sexual content. You get a nice dance from her and can make money too. This then escalates into turning the strip club into a porn studio, where you're the star, but you make sure no one can see your girlfriends face. Sound good? Then you bring other girls to the strip club (now a photoshoot set), so you can make more videos and more content.

Personally I would have no problem with this, but I would not find particularly arousing either since it does not trigger any of my fetishes.

But one of your buddies works there too. When you're at his house, his mother offers you and him special lessons that involve her sucking both of your dicks at the same time; FOR a very good reason I cannot say. So anyways, later that night, you guys are working at the male strip club and his mom comes to visit. She ends up sucking you both off while she's sitting in front of the stripper platform and you two on your knees elevated above her a bit with your big dicks sticking out. His mom his just slobbering on them both to the music, my god. Wait, does this lead to INCEST STRIP CLUB NIGHT? MY DUDE, let go of your possessive nature, lol. Fun aside, I could easily make it so his mom comes to the club only and either:

a) he knows his mom sucks your dick, but there's nothing he can do cuz you're in a position of power over him
b) you do it behind his back

This is very very good. Especially if you go with (b).

Btw I'm not saying that (b) is the way the majority will like, so I'm not sure it's better to go with it. But for me (b) is one thousand times more arousing than (a).

I remember playing a game where you mind controlled and used the mother of your friend behind his back. Even though she was not my type I had to fap to that.

 

[hakarlman]

I can advise you something, I myself plan to use this idea somehow. A restaurant with a "natural" sauce. Imagine, a customer comes in and orders a steak or some rolls. He sits down in his place in front of the reinforced glass, behind which he will be waiting for the order and the girl or boy who will have to give his dish the final shape. The girl squats over a plate of food and begins to masturbate, using only her hand or a toys (girls which can squirt will cost higher), plentifully watering the order with her juices. At this time, the customer can also do whatever he wants, because no one will see him or her, and then he will receive his order with natural sauce. Boy will jerk off and pour the order with sperm.

I like this idea. Here's what I was thinking, cuz I had planned something similar.

The Male MC works at a restaurant. He has a reputation for having a big dick. Husbands who are complete losers and cucks will come to this restaurant during the 'special time'. The husband and wife sit down and you come to their table and ask what they want. She points to an item on the menu: "long, thick cock with four day semen load saved up." .. So you whip out your dick right there and she starts worshipping your dick, sucking it like crazy right in front of her husband. He's devastated and broken, meanwhile his wife is just slobbering all over your dick. You give her an amazing load and she keeps it in her mouth to show you. You're such a good employee that you take a picture of her face with a mouthful of cum, then print it out and give one copy to her and to the husband, because it's two for one special you know.

So next time the same couple comes back, but they brought their daughter so she can learn from her mom. Daughter is 19. Could you ensure her daughter learns how to properly worship your characters big dick?! It will help the community. Word will spread at church of your special services, so lots of married women can come to the restaurant after church and you can help those couples out with your special couples therapy.

From there it could escalate into some really depraved shit, like you pissing inside the mothers mouth and daughters mouth right in front of the husband. But you assure them you've been drinking mineral and vitamin water all day, the expensive stuff, so the husband won't feel disrespected.

 

[GreenGobbo]

Don't have the patience to wade through reading 3 pages of comments so I'm just going to answer the OP as if it were being asked of me directly.

The only way I can see a game with this type of set up NOT scaring away NTR haters is if the women the MC is acquiring for his own personal use are not under any circumstances involved in his business ventures at all.
Just completely divorce the personal life side of the game from the business side of it with no overlap between the characters.



If you actively avoid introducing any of the women who are actually working in the... "establishments" to the player character then you *should* be free to get as creative as you want with the employees in those places and the player (hopefully) would be able to enjoy any scenes with said employees servicing the patrons.




Example:

MC meets four gals named Samantha, Hilda, Amy, and Zoey.
He splits his time between managing his business ventures and wooing the 4 named gals.
The women with actual names may or may not be aware of his work, buuuuuut are never employed at any or visit any of them.

All of the ladies that he does employ there have very generic names like Prostitute 34 and Slut 17.
Acquiring employees can be as easy or complicated as you'd like to make it from a gameplay angle, but once in place it's just a matter of figuring out pay rates, upkeep costs, and maybe sick leave or fatigue for the employee.

Samantha, Hilda, Amy, and Zoey on the other hand (all being the MC's actual girlfriends) would bring in a wholly separate game play dynamic based on getting them to like you and each other more. They don't meet anyone else, they don't show any signs of interest in any one else, and they never never never get involved with the business side of the game.


Ideally it would even free you up to use totally random characters for use to see how things are going in the brothels and strip-club via CCTV cameras or whatever.
MC checks camera 1: Random Prostitute 1 is blowing some random customer on a leather couch.
MC checks camera 2: Random Prostitute 2 has been put into some stocks and is getting plowed from behind.
MC checks camera 3: Random Prostitute 3 is giving someone a very special lapdance in the champagne room at the strip club.
Etcetera, etc., etc. ...

Just make sure never to re-use the same models from one employee scene to the next.
Each new "work" scene should have a completely different woman involved.
That should keep players from forming any attachments to them, and it would help in making it seem more random and less personal.

At least that's how I would go about it if I knew anything about making games and was attempting to quell the no-ntr crowds.

 

[hakarlman]

personal.

At least that's how I would go about it if I knew anything about making games and was attempting to quell the no-ntr crowds.

I can't possibly do what you suggest. It would be splitting the game into two mini games; but within one game. Example:

a) Innocent House Simulator "hey sister, do you like candy? you do? Me too. You like flowers? Me to, want to have sex? Okay!"
b) Sinful City filled with Crime & Debauchery

I've actually figured out how to make about 70% of the existing content work for Non-NTR, but I still really want to see what someone who dislikes NTR comes up with; how to make a brothel, whore house, gloryhole, sex club be highly erotic in a non-ntr setting, in which you have three women who are very loyal to you; mother, sister, girlfriend.

 

[Lerd0]

...

Can just do it like i used to play those brothel sims, keep some bitches for urself, either lazing around doing nothing while i simped for them, or putting them to work on menial non-sexual tasks, and let every bitch u don't care about whore around.

 

[paust.alex]

a) Innocent House Simulator "hey sister, do you like candy? you do? Me too. You like flowers? Me to, want to have sex? Okay!"
b) Sinful City filled with Crime & Debauchery

What's so bad about that? Do you think you won't want to come home after a day of corruption and debauchery and feel the light touch of innocent love?

 

[GreenGobbo]

I can't possibly do what you suggest. It would be splitting the game into two mini games; but within one game. Example:

a) Innocent House Simulator "hey sister, do you like candy? you do? Me too. You like flowers? Me to, want to have sex? Okay!"
b) Sinful City filled with Crime & Debauchery

I've actually figured out how to make about 70% of the existing content work for Non-NTR, but I still really want to see what someone who dislikes NTR comes up with; how to make a brothel, whore house, gloryhole, sex club be highly erotic in a non-ntr setting, in which you have three women who are very loyal to you; mother, sister, girlfriend.

I wasn't trying to suggest everything is all sunny and roses at home. There's plenty of ways to get dark and gritty without sharing or pimping out your girls.

Fair enough though, it is your game after all. I personally don't see how keeping home life and work life separate in a video game is impossible, but I don't know shit about make games anyway so ymmv...

Anyhow good luck with it.
I'll just get out of your hair and focus on playing something completely different.
Have a good one.

 

[hakarlman]

What's so bad about that? Do you think you won't want to come home after a day of corruption and debauchery and feel the light touch of innocent love?

You're right. Just to clarify, you do have a home in the game and you can have a very loving and deep romantic relationship with two of the women, but they'll be part of the sinful city, not protected from it, they'll be in the shit with you side by side; and for a very good reason that makes sense.

 

[hakarlman]

I wasn't trying to suggest everything is all sunny and roses at home. There's plenty of ways to get dark and gritty without sharing or pimping out your girls.

I'm totally open to that. Can you think of some ways where your girls can somehow take part in a brothel, strip club, sex club, or gloryhole without NTR? Something that you find VERY erotic, but without the NTR? Get as creative as you can!

I've already figured out some pretty good ideas for the strip club, so the MC can have fun there without ANY ntr whatsoever. It's actually a nice twist. Because normally people think, oh strip club, strippers, it's kind of predictable, but you'll be able to do something unique to the strip club, out of the norm, should be exciting.

 

[Ferlucio]

I don't hate NTR with a passion, but I do dislike it overall, maybe because my first experience with it was Thug Hero Party.

The problem with NTR haters is that they stretch the definition too much. If the protag is the owner of a brothel and has girls servicing customers, that is not NTR because the protag and the girls are not in a "Loving relationship". It's only NTR if 2 characters have a loving relationship (lovers/family etc).

I'd have to agree to what was said before, lots of games where NTR is avoidable have very little non-NTR content or even none at all and what is there is bland and boring. And as long as NTR as I've described it is avoidable I will play the game, and if the NTR is avoidable I'll even play through the NTR scenes in a gallery or on a fast second playthrough as in my head I can see it as an "what if" scenario and disconnect from it emotionally. That's also what a lot of NTR lovers don't think of or don't understand, the reason some people dislike or hate Netorare specifically is because the story is aimed at emotionally hurting the reader, who identifies or at least perceives the story through the protagonist, rather then just showing the act of cheating. Some NTR lovers advise to imagine yourself as the other party, identify with the character who is stealing the protagonist's girl, but that is not how Netorare story is structured and told, the writer want's you to relate with the protagonist and suffer with the protagonist, so if you enjoy netorare by imagining you as the one doing the stealing, you're doing it wrong, and what you really want is netori.

Sorry for the long rant if it turns out to be useless.

As for a interesting scene I think will please both sides, and surely will please me, here me out: The protagonist needs to sex train a new girl for the job but he doesn't just use his own body to teach her, instead he gets some other guy to be a test dummy, maybe a male friend of the protagonist, and tells the new girl what and how to do and how to behave to better please clients. Basically the protag is still in control at all times even if he is not the one doing the fucking, so all but the NTR-hating purists will be able to enjoy such a scene.

Hope any of my ranting was of any use at all. And:


Edit: Just noticed the last post and wanted to answer your question about main girls in non-ntr things. Depends what kinda things you thinking about! You can have the main girls do bartending, gather info about clients from the prostitutes , maybe even be a bouncer if their character allows it. For my taste I'd even allow them to do striptease for the clients as long as it's "Look only" but I can see lotsa people wouldn't want that. Maybe one of them is a sort of emotional relieve for the prostitutes , you know the sort of girl that can help and support them emotionally and such. Basically anything that doesn't involve the main girls touching other men/clients is free real estate IMHO.