Seeking Adult VN tailored for my weird preferences? (GFD,SoF)

Oct 21, 2023
99
79
TL;DR
Looking for next VN to play, I liked only Nothing is Forever and Goodbye Eternity so far.

Hey!


I just finished Nothing is Forever. I played GE, AC, Android Life aaaand I think that's that. I mean I played a lot more but they're either bad, or took me 30 minutes to finish so I don't even bother mentioning. Here's my thoughts so far about VN's:

1. NiF had best writing from all the VN I played, nothing comes even close... For the first time I saw lines that I could actually imagine being said in real life
2. Also was the most adult, everything other I tried more or less but sadly falls into category of "things that I would write if I tried to do VN when I was 14". Too often I feel like reading a script made by someone who never interacted with real woman :/
3. Real topics (the leak issue for example) and not some magical potion bullshit. I don't mean that it has to be 100% realistic, I'm fine with fantasy, sci fi, whatever. But if we go for school setting, don't make me safe a world?
4. Femdom, duh - although I need to test in future NG+ because my first attempt resulted in too humiliating kind - I prefer aftercare, gentle style. Not a requirement 100% though, might be vanilla (just not maledom)
5a. Not a fan of that 3d engine tbh, it's better than bad drawing (I'd put it sliiightly better than Another Chance) but if it had Goodbye Eternity art... Nothing beats the first sex scene of that game. But I don't expect another original art (cause I'd find it on my own after spending sometimes hours every day browsing vndb, f95 and others) so I think the best scenario would be...
5b. Live2D or whatever is the thing called? Kajiu Princess, or what all the Vtubers use - actually I wonder why it's not that broadly used? I am tempted to force GPT to spill me some script, hook up that thing to make some nice animations and pics etc., and make more pleasant to look at VN than I'd say 80% of latest updates ;_;
5c. Icha Icha Steady is the closest thing to what would be perfect VN in terms of looks... if for some goddamn reasons it didn't switched to ugly 2d drawings for sex scenes. I know it's not possible to do H-scene with those models probably, but I'd rather have to imagine them than to watch those stupidly oversized breasts drawings from weird angles.
6. Pacing - I hate opening the game and be greeted by Heroine begging to fuck her. Nothing is forever was pretty good at it. GE handled it nicely as well, satisfying thirst for erotic scene by showing some masturbation instead. Let me meet the characters at least a little before I giving me "fuck her? yes/no" screen
7. Choices - there's no coincidence probably that those 2 most mentioned by me games are also ones with a lot opposite parts - I guess maybe it's due to fact, that if a dev team manages to implement Maledom and Famedom into one game, with one Hero, it means they are competent enough to make other things work well too. So yeah - I like them. But I don't need as complex (although I really enjoy it!) system as NiF with all the stat points and traits. Give me kinetic novel, that throws one but meaningful and nice choice every hour and I'd be satisfied as well.
8. Lenght - in perfect world my perfect game would be endless, like a TV show, 13 seasons and still rolling. I know there's nothing like that, but at least let it be long enough to "last" at least few days of 2-4h sessions everyday? But don't mistake it for... bloatiness. Coming back to point 1. - i want real conversations, not a single reply to consist 5 pages of text...

What do you suggest to pick up next? (if you're bored you can write the points that the game has or is lacking of, like "1,3,6,7")
Do you think something might slip under my radar in my extensive (and I mean it, trust me) search?
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: qewretryt
Oct 21, 2023
99
79
Maybe something like this?
Thank you very much! On the first glance they don't seem to be something I won't enjoy, especially first couple!
I guess I didn't thought about it being optional - I always excluded incest and rape tags whenever searching for things :FacePalm:
 

Jaike

Well-Known Member
Aug 24, 2020
1,332
4,484
I can think of 2 2d games you may like. Old stuff, though.

The first one is Sanguine Rose. Classic VN structure with significant branching. It has maledom too, tho, but there's also femdom.

The other is maybe a long shot, it has a lesbian protagonist and I don't know if you like that. Ladykiller in a Bind. The structure is more unusual, like a sandbox with scoring and scene select, and it has the most dynamic choice structure I've seen in any Ren'Py VN.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon670-1
Oct 21, 2023
99
79
I can think of 2 2d games you may like. Old stuff, though.

The first one is Sanguine Rose. Classic VN structure with significant branching. It has maledom too, tho, but there's also femdom.

The other is maybe a long shot, it has a lesbian protagonist and I don't know if you like that. Ladykiller in a Bind. The structure is more unusual, like a sandbox with scoring and scene select, and it has the most dynamic choice structure I've seen in any Ren'Py VN.
Appriciate really you posting! But that's not quite what I look for.
I am too primitive to immerse myself properly into female character sadly.
And as for the first - I really disliked it.. I'd say even it's the opposite of what I look for!

Which can be a point in itself:
9. I really hate those gacha-VN that claim to have 20 hours of gameplay in them, but it's 20 different storypaths, that you complete in 15 minutes each, and then you're supposed to replay it over and over again and "discover alternative endings!!!".
Bleh.
 

Mememe621

Newbie
May 12, 2017
91
70
What do you suggest to pick up next? (if you're bored you can write the points that the game has or is lacking of, like "1,3,6,7")
Do you think something might slip under my radar in my extensive (and I mean it, trust me) search?
Can't say I can give you games that meet all of these criteria, but I'll take a shot:
  • Have you played Sexbot? If not, it's worth your time. Writing is excellent, but it's very goofy, not "serious" like NiF. Tons of content at this point, including a fair amount of gentle femdom. 3d art, but very well-done for what it is.
  • Club Detention has sub/dom options and is pretty well-written, from what I can remember.
  • SpaceCorps XXX has lots of options including femdom ones. SciFi, obviously, but the writing is less juvenile than most games out there.
  • If you can get into a futa game, what about Futagenesis Unveiled? It's entirely Futa x Female, MC has the only dick in the game. The writing is very good, despite the crazy premise, and a lot of scenes have a slightly femdom-ish feel. Having a Hard Time has a pretty similar vibe. Unfortunately both games are still relatively short.
 
  • Like
Reactions: anon670-1
Oct 21, 2023
99
79
Caught but the nice visuals I checked https://f95zone.to/threads/my-hero-rising-v0-75-daraus.89991/ - I actually haven't - please don't take it personally, probably it's just my unique approach to VN's - played worse game in terms of mechanics :')

Mememe621 just as with Jaike I appriciate really your input into the discussion! That said - just judging from the f95 post of it I know it's not what I look for.

MaximMuster - I checked https://f95zone.to/threads/the-deluca-family-v0-09-6-hopesgaming.15459/ first as it seemed most intriguing - I haven't even managed to start playing the game. Just from the way the game's Intro (mentioned above 5 page essey in the back of a car) prevents me from checking the rest of the game.
On the other hand the game I checked next - https://f95zone.to/threads/elvensang-ep-5-worlaix.76008/ looks really promising! I reached the part of arriving home with S for the first time, so I hope - barely started a game. But if the rest will be as much enjoyable as that introduction - it might even take a lead in my personal ranking. Really nice writing so far!
 
Last edited:
Oct 21, 2023
99
79
Maybe something like this?
https://f95zone.to/threads/elvensang-ep-5-worlaix.76008/
8/10, gentle, romantic, no corruption, I need more of that - a damsel in distress that MC wants to shelter from all that is evil, and vice versa - jealousy is my #1 kink lately. Plus no "comedy", no 4th wall breaking, it actually felt like consuming a normal story, and not a VN. After Goodbye Eternity I was really excited about more sandbox games, but those I tried after are soooo messy, buggy, awfuly coded and incoherent...
No, give me this kinetic vibe with few crucial choices. It would be 10/10 if not for the art lacking in first acts, but it has also one of the best ones I've seen. So yeah - even though Arrogant Kaiju Princess is my Top 1 game JUST because of it's Art - I do not need it to have fun, quite the contrary. I want immersion.
I want more cuddling! :'(
https://f95zone.to/threads/randel-tales-v1-4-6-bunis-rin.47906/
https://f95zone.to/threads/what-a-legend-v0-6-02-magicnuts.51349/
Yeah no, thank you. As staited above - sandbox feel tiring and unnecessary, and the "humor" just doesnt work for me. I want serious drama and dillemas, not scenes of "being so horny you get hard when seeing 90 old grandma"

https://f95zone.to/threads/light-of-my-life-ch-1-7-v1-0-0-naughty-road.29628/
https://f95zone.to/threads/one-day-at-a-time-ch-16c-zoey-raven.67104/
https://f95zone.to/threads/price-of-power-ch-20-pandaman-games.72109/
https://f95zone.to/threads/the-deluca-family-v0-09-6-hopesgaming.15459/
I think I need more time before I check any 3d one again. Half of the faces look like I saw them in NiF, others look creepy or just ugly.

https://f95zone.to/threads/bishoujo-mangekyou-a-girls-cursed-legend-final-wstar.19142/
For the legal reasons I have to say that I totally did not enjoy this one. But the femdomish parts I didn't enjoyed little less.

https://f95zone.to/threads/seeds-of-chaos-v0-4-03-dev-venus-noire.26/
I don't really care about side-quests, I hate the gameplay, I cannot stand NTR.
I skipped through them, I lost the game because of it, I replaced "wife" word with "sister" with 3rd party mod.
But it has beautiful art and actually fun Jezera plotline which I want to explore, but I will have to start over from beginning and actually focus what is the objective in game :D



I have this list for my next target
Any suggestions? Anything to drop?
Are there any WORKING engines that can analyse vndb profiles and reccomend things?
 

qewretryt

New Member
Apr 22, 2024
1
0
bump for the 99% similar favor of AVN as OP. would like to explore more games like Goodbye Eternity.