4.50 star(s) 280 Votes

Walter Victor

Forum Fanatic
Dec 27, 2017
5,545
19,278
How is it irrelevant? He would know his ex girlfriends last name, but he would not know her future married name. So even knowing Melodies last name now, does not mean that it was her mothers maiden name, the name that he would know.
I didn't bring up last names. And I still don't know why you did.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
U

User_130505

Guest
Guest
They also never, not once gave Melodys mothers first name.
All that we do know, is that she was Amy's older sister.
What we do know, is that her mother named her Melody, because her mother loved music, and had dated a musician in college.
 
U

User_130505

Guest
Guest
I just went thru the beginning of the game again, and all I have found is "her older sister." That was said in the diner where they first met to discuss the guitar.
And even with a first name, does that mean he is going to jump up and say, "I dated a girl with that name before!"
Now if it were a first and a last name that he recognized, then yeah, he would have said, "Hold on a minute, tell me about her"
Basically he would have asked direct questions, if he had thought that the girl he dated in college was the same person. A first name only, would not prompt such a response. Try googling your own full name and unless you have a strange one, you will find out that you are not alone.
In the state that I live in alone, 70 people have the same first and last name as mine, but there would be thousands with just my first name.

For example, according to Google, there are 1,527,408 people in the U.S. named Jennifer.
There are 661,933 people in the U.S. with the first name Amanda.
Do you see my point. A first name is not much to get excited about. A lot of people have the same first names, but if you attach a last name to that first name, you may still have a few thousand in the country, but it would be enough to prompt asking for further details.
 

BigBabs69

Active Member
Mar 3, 2017
779
943
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I also thought that the mc could be the dad back on page 21,I'm the OG dad theorist :p
But i gave up on that theory as we got more info on the mom,just can't find where that info was,that led me to give up on the theory and don't feel like replaying the game,soooo...i guess we will find out if the dev is sneaking around patreon tos later in the game >.>
 
  • Like
Reactions: Davisow
U

User_130505

Guest
Guest
OK, I was mistaken about them not giving the name, but look on Google, and you will see this.
A few facts about the girl's name Melissa: Records indicate that 745,408 girls in the United States are named Melissa.
As I said a few minutes ago, a first name is not enough to really get anyone to think that they could be the same people.
 
U

User_130505

Guest
Guest
745,408 girls in the United States are named Melissa.
it is common
 

Walter Victor

Forum Fanatic
Dec 27, 2017
5,545
19,278
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I also thought that the mc could be the dad back on page 21,I'm the OG dad theorist :p
But i gave up on that theory as we got more info on the mom,just can't find where that info was,that led me to give up on the theory and don't feel like replaying the game,soooo...i guess we will find out if the dev is sneaking around patreon tos later in the game >.>
Yeah. We won't really know until the game plays out.
 

fauxplayer

Engaged Member
Uploader
Donor
May 28, 2017
2,278
13,054
This page is truly brilliant. Just truly, outstandingly, brilliant.

WV: I'm talking about Melissa
WTW: I'm talking about Melody's mom
WV: We're talking about the same person
WTW: No, I'm talking about the MC's ex-girlfriend
WV: Right. Melissa.
WTW: No, Melody's mom.
WV: Yea, the MC's ex-girlfriend.
WTW: Her name I Melissa.
WV: Yes.

This conversation is like:

 

Walter Victor

Forum Fanatic
Dec 27, 2017
5,545
19,278
This page is truly brilliant. Just truly, outstandingly, brilliant.

WV: I'm talking about Melissa
WTW: I'm talking about Melody's mom
WV: We're talking about the same person
WTW: No, I'm talking about the MC's ex-girlfriend
WV: Right. Melissa.
WTW: No, Melody's mom.
WV: Yea, the MC's ex-girlfriend.
WTW: Her name I Melissa.
WV: Yes.

This conversation is like:

Do you think our routine will work in Vaudeville? We have the opportunity to open in Cucamonga over the weekend.
 

JasonC69

New Member
Aug 20, 2018
1
2
Just gonna jump in here and say how much I love this game / novel. Am still a fan of DMD, but agree with others here that the character development and writing in general of Melody is much better. D of DMD is so cute and sexy (though whiny, e.g., 'What are you doing, Daddy?' ad nauseam). The story is just dragging, IMO.

However I'm really liking the pace of Melody so far, and the depth of the title and main characters. She is also so beautiful, as is the rest of the artwork (as aways by Mr. Dots and team). I too want to know more about her mother and the possibilities that her and MC's past lives could have crossed.

Anyways, just my current thoughts as well as a shout out to this community!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Centurion and JeefZ

ShiShi!

Member
Nov 28, 2017
456
510
745,408 girls in the United States are named Melissa.
it is common
You can't seriously apply that kind of logic in this game, especially considering the situation with Patreon and what MrDot's most popular game is known for. Yes first names are common, we know that, but you are trying too hard to analyze it realistically. Not quite a coincidence when MrDot purposefully let the characters mentioned the name of Melody's mother let it be known that it was also the name of his ex-girlfriend, there are millions of name out there that he could have picked if you want to use statistics.

Amy and Arnold even appears in DMD's latest chapter, albeit only in background and not mentioned, just goes to show that these "coincidences" are planned and put it the game for a reason. I'm sure it's a simple hint for the incest lovers to fantasize on their own without directly making it too obvious so Patreon doesn't knock on his door.
 

Walter Victor

Forum Fanatic
Dec 27, 2017
5,545
19,278
Not quite a coincidence when MrDot purposefully let the characters mentioned the name of Melody's mother let it be known that it was also the name of his ex-girlfriend, there are millions of name out there that he could have picked if you want to use statistics.
I must have missed it. Where did anyone say what the name of the MC's ex-girlfriend was? I am sure she had a name. But I don't remember anyone mentioning it. Other than the MC, only Tim or Isabella could possibly know it. Did one of them mention it? Where?

If it happened, I will change my position on this subject.
 

ShiShi!

Member
Nov 28, 2017
456
510
I must have missed it. Where did anyone say what the name of the MC's ex-girlfriend was? I am sure she had a name. But I don't remember anyone mentioning it. Other than the MC, only Tim or Isabella could possibly know it. Did one of them mention it? Where?

If it happened, I will change my position on this subject.
My mistake, the cross-reference of how his ex dropped out of college and suddenly disappeared and the similar history/or story told by Melody of how she was pulled out suddenly is what I meant when I said MrDot let it be known that it was a hint at his ex-girlfriend thus possibly being Melody's father.

As I said, this is just simply a POSSIBLE hint for incest lovers, open to them to fantasize, I'm sure there's a fetish out there for people who likes incest without the main characters actually knowing, if you are not an incest lover, then you are free to choose to believe that it's nothing.
 

Walter Victor

Forum Fanatic
Dec 27, 2017
5,545
19,278
My mistake, the cross-reference of how his ex dropped out of college and suddenly disappeared and the similar history/or story told by Melody of how she was pulled out suddenly is what I meant when I said MrDot let it be known that it was a hint at his ex-girlfriend thus possibly being Melody's father.

As I said, this is just simply a POSSIBLE hint for incest lovers, open to them to fantasize, I'm sure there's a fetish out there for people who likes incest without the main characters actually knowing, if you are not an incest lover, then you are free to choose to believe that it's nothing.
Ok, got it.

Actually, I am an incest-game lover. The large majority of the porn games that I play involve incest. But, a good porn game is a good porn game, and this is a VERY good porn game.

I just don't think it's happening in this game, for reasons I have spelled out previously. If it does, I'll be interested to see how Mr Dots gets around my argument against it... or ignores it, for that matter. Regardless, I'll continue to play the game.
 
Sep 21, 2017
1,017
1,075
gadd my blue balls are turning purple...I just played a recent update of another game and I`m craving for MOAR!!:WutFace: FUCKKKKK.....:tf:
I`m lurking around and checking some of the games I`m waiting for updates and so far other than THAT recent game...no updates here amongst others:FeelsBadMan:
 
4.50 star(s) 280 Votes