Female Protagonist vs. Male Protagonist... what ya thinkin' brah?

What do you prefer?

  • Female Protagonists

    Votes: 93 54.1%
  • Male Protagonists

    Votes: 79 45.9%

  • Total voters
    172

samoo

Formerly 'samosamy'
Jan 11, 2019
40
41
#21
Western male: Big Brother, Dating my Daughter
are you really mentioning big brother and dating my daughter in the same comment

you should know before play

big brother (that the game based on NTR)
-you may watch your mother being fucked in front of you
-the same with your sisters and aunt

dating my daughter
-the game based on romance between dad and daughter
-the game contain no NTR

the opposite 2 different games for two different type of people so you cannot suggest the two of them to the same person
 
Mar 9, 2018
68
61
#22
anyway when i play a female protagonist game i cannot let the girl fucked by anyone ... i don't know why iam over protective for her but i really tried many game because when i play with a girl i consider my self the girl and that's wrong so i avoided
HAHAHA! That's fucking priceless dude...!

but believe me you problem is simple if what you are saying is true that the problem with character development and the story
then ..
why don't you just try the right male protagonist game ??
Oh, there are quite a few male protagonist games that I like. Games such as Depraved Awakenings, My Sweet Neighbors, Acting Lessons, My Girlfriends Amnesia, Deviant Discoveries, Lancaster Boarding House etc.

let me as you another question if you are watching a porn movie so do you consider yourself the male who is fucking the girl
or the female who is being fucked my the man (of course you are the male) unless you watching it as a third person too :D

then maybe you are just a voyeurism (discover what you really like and you will be more stasified with the game you play )
For fuck sake dude! HAHAHA! I mean, it's nice that you're trying to help me expand my taste, and I really appreciate that. But this thread wasn't exactly meant as a cry for help. :) It was meant to simply open a dialogue with other people to try and explore the underlying mechanics of male vs. female protagonist adult games.

@Avaron1974
you specially should avoid female protagonist games because
-most of them about the female getting raped
-the rest about a lesbian woman turned to be a straight woman
-every female western game until now developed for male too
-they are mixing tastes and making it impossible
-so me as a male and have no experience about lesbians i could get the wrong impression
Who's this dude creeping into your correspondance?
 
Mar 9, 2018
68
61
#23
Sure. Just on top of my head:

Western male: Big Brother, Dating my Daughter, Harem Hotel
Western female: Road Trip, Katie's Corruption

Japanese male: 99% of visual novels with a school setting like Koi to Senkyo to Chocolate, Wagamama High Spec...
Japanese female: otome games with actual porn like Chou no Doku Hana no Kusari (though it has a rich MC) or Under the Moon

There's also the case of all Japanese RPG Maker dungeon crawlers with rape-on-defeat but for them the protagonist tend to be similar to western female ones.
Cools beans. I know some of em but not all.
 

Kukothemadhatter

Well-Known Member
Sep 29, 2017
2,112
1,731
#24
I tend to go for immersion so female MC is the way for me but I also tend to go for lesbian content which isn't exactly in abundance and there is a lot of content involving female protags that isn't my kink like corruption and rape.

I do generally avoid male protag games.
I play male MC when I want to go for immersion and something I wouldn;t want to do in real life, and when I want to be a pervy observer I go for games like A wife and a mother
 
Likes: SAFFID
Mar 9, 2018
68
61
#25
are you really mentioning big brother and dating my daughter in the same comment

you should know before play

big brother (that the game based on NTR)
-you may watch your mother being fucked in front of you
-the same with your sisters and aunt

dating my daughter
-the game based on romance between dad and daughter
-the game contain no NTR

the opposite 2 different games for two different type of people so you cannot suggest the two of them to the same person
Nah fam! Don't worry bout it. I got mad wide taste! :) Anyway, the point wasn't to give me suggestions, I just wanted to gain an understanding as to which games fit the aforementioned outlined criteria.
 

samoo

Formerly 'samosamy'
Jan 11, 2019
40
41
#26
this thread wasn't exactly meant as a cry for help. :) It was meant to simply open a dialogue with other people to try and explore the underlying mechanics of male vs. female protagonist adult games
no way iam going to ruin this thread for you whatever it takes (oh just kidding :love:)
i will leave for now don't push my trigger again :p
 
Likes: SAFFID

random.guy

Well-Known Member
Aug 11, 2017
543
724
#28
I voted female because shitty Japanese RPGM corruption games are my drug.
I bask in the sense of humiliation, degradation and shame and it's quite cathartic to act as a character who feels all of those until she sheds them like a snake's skin and rebirths as a moral abomination.

Male characters are good for impregnation fetish though. That's the stuff too.
 
Mar 9, 2018
68
61
#29
I bask in the sense of humiliation, degradation and shame and it's quite cathartic to act as a character who feels all of those until she sheds them like a snake's skin and rebirths as a moral abomination.
HOLY FUCK! Well put mate. Couldn't have described that feeling better myself.
I can enjoy that type of game as well. Not to put you on the spot or anything, but could you suggest a few of you favorites?
 

MrBree

Active Member
Jun 9, 2017
106
68
#30
As mentioned twice here, Female protag games are often corruption games. Which means one or more of corruption, rape, BSDM, degradation, humiliation; etc.

A woman actually interested in her sexuality? Heaven forbid! She must be forced and brutalized into it.

Not my kink at all.

That plus the fact that I am throughly heterosexual and cannot identify with a protagonist who finds men attractive. So this category rarely provides anything that sates my interests.
 
Mar 9, 2018
68
61
#31
I like to play men.

You can have sex with many different women.
As a woman, most of you only have sex with different men and women are not exciting.
I also love to impregnate mothers or sisters.

As a woman you do not have these possibilities.
Interesting. I never really understood the impregnation fetish though. But, you know, to each his own, right...
I don't know what it is really. It might be something wholly connected to nature where, you know, a pregnant woman is like a woman taken out of sexual circulation. :) As soon as she is pregnant she is basically sexually invisible to me. It really speaks to a completely animalistic view on sex, where the sole purpose of the act itself is procreation. Of course, one might be able to simply turn that logic on it's head and say; that's exactly why impregnation is desirable. Who knows man... maybe we just like what we like.
 
Likes: netsrac

random.guy

Well-Known Member
Aug 11, 2017
543
724
#32
HOLY FUCK! Well put mate. Couldn't have described that feeling better myself.
I can enjoy that type of game as well. Not to put you on the spot or anything, but could you suggest a few of you favorites?
I'm terrible at making examples °w°
And I enjoy the genre so much that I can pass for good even not so high-quality stuff, so I'm definitely not the person to ask for suggestions.
 

freedom.call

Well-Known Member
Donor
Mar 8, 2018
462
476
#34
I play both, if I like the game I don't really care what I am in game. I like being a 'seasoned veteran' over a blabbering teen though, kinda tired of shouting at the screen and the idiot kid blundering about wondering if the other person actually said what they said blah blah. ;)
 
Likes: SAFFID

carnalcardinal

First of Her Name,Cuckquean of the Andes+Best Men
Game Developer
Jr. Uploader
Jul 28, 2017
1,257
3,368
#35
Interesting. I never really understood the impregnation fetish though. But, you know, to each his own, right...
I don't know what it is really. It might be something wholly connected to nature where, you know, a pregnant woman is like a woman taken out of sexual circulation. :) As soon as she is pregnant she is basically sexually invisible to me. It really speaks to a completely animalistic view on sex, where the sole purpose of the act itself is procreation. Of course, one might be able to simply turn that logic on it's head and say; that's exactly why impregnation is desirable. Who knows man... maybe we just like what we like.
Some people are also just attracted to people who are pregnant. I've had a whole different subset of men flirting with me ever since I started showing.

Also, love the Avatar. Simon > Negan.
 
Likes: SAFFID

Rythan25

Well-Known Member
Feb 20, 2018
781
747
#36
Male protagonist by a LANDSLIDE... Show me more than one or two good female protagonist games, and I might consider either changing my view or making it more 50/50...

Male-led games are usually either awesome harem games (with or without incest) or lame cuck/ntr games, but usually the male makes purposely good or bad decisions... (HE MAKES them !) not the secondary characters...

Female-led games usually make the protagonist a brain dead moron in a town full of rapist assholes...Some pump-less loser goes up the female MC and says "suck my dickens, or I will tell something to someone and ruin your life also I dont have proof", and then the dumb bitch does it... rather than telling him to go fuck himself and send him to jail where said loser gets his ass destroyed by a dude named Molly..
 

Ataios

Well-Known Member
Sep 11, 2017
469
340
#37
I prefer lesbian games to straight ones, so it's mostly female protagonists for me. For those straight I do play though, I prefer male protagonists. Given the choice I don't want my female protagonists to have sex with male characters.
 
Mar 9, 2018
68
61
#38
Some people are also just attracted to people who are pregnant. I've had a whole different subset of men flirting with me ever since I started showing.
Really? That's so interesting man. I'd love to understand more about the psychology of those kinds of fetishes.

Also, love the Avatar. Simon > Negan.
Most def! Simon is the real boss of the show... if being 'the real boss' means being the biggest psycho. :)
 
Mar 9, 2018
68
61
#39
Male protagonist by a LANDSLIDE... Show me more than one or two good female protagonist games, and I might consider either changing my view or making it more 50/50...

Male-led games are usually either awesome harem games (with or without incest) or lame cuck/ntr games, but usually the male makes purposely good or bad decisions... (HE MAKES them !) not the secondary characters...

Female-led games usually make the protagonist a brain dead moron in a town full of rapist assholes...Some pump-less loser goes up the female MC and says "suck my dickens, or I will tell something to someone and ruin your life also I dont have proof", and then the dumb bitch does it... rather than telling him to go fuck himself and send him to jail where said loser gets his ass destroyed by a dude named Molly..
Thanks for you response man.

I agree with you on many of your points. A lot of these female protagonist games DO in fact entail cuck/ntr, the protagonist is not especially good at getting herself out of undesired sexual situations, and the town is usually filled with what you called rapist assholes. You are absolutely right about all that. So if we use those as a template/outline/criteria (our very own no-no-list), we are now looking for a "good female protagonist game" with no ntr, a non-stupid protagonist, and non-rapisty secondary characters. Here are two suggestions for female protagonist games you might enjoy (I added a little description):

- "Good Girl Gone Bad" by EvaKiss
This game has a multitude of possible storylines and character developments dependent on player-choices (and it ACTUALLY works in this game). So a game that could/should be played multiple times. If you don't want ntr then just break up with the boyfriend, or be faithful to him.


- "Zoe's Temptations" by Daniels K [Completed]
Female Protagonist faced with a choice between 'pure' or 'deviant', but there are equal sex scenes on both sides, so don't worry too much about that. Great storyline also. The main character pretty quickly takes charge of her own sexuality in this one.


I mean, I could list a bunch more games that I personally find to be "good games" but most of them wouldn't live up to our other three criterias. But then again, seriously dude, if you are concerned about these 'rapist assholes' you really shouldn't be, cos in the vast majority of the female protagonist games you get to make a decision. Yeah sure, the males are a little pushy, but you can alway say 'no'. I mean, you don't HAVE to just fuck everybody who speaks to you. But then again, I think you might simply be right in your evaluation of you own taste in games. I think fem protags might just not be for you and that's cool. We don't have to all enjoy the same shit. It's funny though, cos when you list all the things that you try to avoid in a game, I'm literally thinking: "But that's all the good shit! That's all the shit I'm looking for in a game.' HAHA!
We're all just different I guess. But hey, that's the beauty of this whole sexuality clusterfuck we're living; it's each our own, man. Namaste.
 
Feb 6, 2018
72
41
#40
are you really mentioning big brother and dating my daughter in the same comment

you should know before play

big brother (that the game based on NTR)
-you may watch your mother being fucked in front of you
-the same with your sisters and aunt

dating my daughter
-the game based on romance between dad and daughter
-the game contain no NTR

the opposite 2 different games for two different type of people so you cannot suggest the two of them to the same person
What does this have to do with the point I was making? He asked me games featuring the kind of protagonist archetypes I described and I did just that. Regardless of the plot both of these games feature a personality-less creep as the main character.
 

Create an account or login to comment

You must be a member in order to leave a comment

Create account

Create an account on our community. It's easy!

Log in

Already have an account? Log in here.