What are your thoughts on games with female protagonist?

Sphere42

Active Member
Sep 9, 2018
914
960
Did you read what my work looks like? I work only with girls and if you think most of them are ugly crackwhores youre absolutly wrong...and i have to listen, care, organize, help, ...and thats only under best conditions, there are many who need far more help...its not easy to wash and change the clothes of drunk/high/apathic/unconscious girls and stay dry...and no, i dont mean water from the shower...in other words, you descriped my permanent condition 12-14 hours per day...thats why i play male protagonist games in my office if i have time...i cannot pet my kitty is the door could open any second, so i need to disgust me down...well, it helps to not jump anyone, but i still need to change every 3-4 hours...and no, going without panties is not an option...how do they say in the games here? Dripping wet...thats not always an overstatement...and really frustrating in winter...
Okay, that sounds rough :( Can't really relate sadly, I've never worked in public service or medical so "focus on work" always was an option.

A little cosplay can be nice to warm up, but not such things like you described. Sadly its a useless Tag for games, who needs a girl dressed as neko if there are running nekos around?
"Cosplay" also includes dressing up as Lara Croft or lesbian vampires, but mostly it brings my hopes up for visual customisation in general. And keep in mind cats have very rough tongues so depending on your preferences a human girl with fake cat ears might be preferable (please do not feel compelled to reply to this part!)
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Virulenz

Virulenz

Engaged Member
Sep 27, 2017
2,821
3,531
Well, what would you prefer? A virtual girl in a game with school setting who cosplays a scene as Lara Croft or a Lara Croft parody game? It is a whole different Level if you have a real cosplayer, but it makes no sense in games.
 

Sphere42

Active Member
Sep 9, 2018
914
960
Well, what would you prefer? A virtual girl in a game with school setting who cosplays a scene as Lara Croft or a Lara Croft parody game? It is a whole different Level if you have a real cosplayer, but it makes no sense in games.
Roleplaying an entire scene would be slightly different, and with most games not really distinguishable from a straight-up parody game unless they explicitly add out-of-character moments. There the direct parody clearly wins out.

But it can still be fun to have characters walking around a completely different setting (especially since the costumes will often be much more interesting than the original character designs...) and for something like "Wonder Woman walking around school campus and making out in the dorms" I would honestly prefer dressup because it's just too jarring and out-of-character for the real thing. And don't forget the mix-and-match possibilities, in something like Honey Select you can create a passing imitation of Sylvanas Windrunner and dress her up in Lara Croft's outfit (at least I assume someone made a mod for that, I haven't looked for Lara specifically).
 

pasunna

Member
Game Developer
Feb 11, 2019
284
293
As a woman who almost exclusively enjoys fem. protag games, I'm probably just an outlier here. But what the heck, why not.

To be clear, I'm not really into ladies. I can appreciate a beautiful woman for what she is, but I'm not attracted to her. So that's not an argument I want to make or have to defend.

Why I prefer female MCs comes mostly down to the actual setting of the game/story. From my experience, male protag games are usually prominently dominant. Which means that fucking as many girls as possible is a goal, if not the goal.
On the other hand, for female MCs the sexual act is usually something she reluctantly agrees upon. She doesn't want it at first, but the narrative puts her into a position in which she has to adapt to these kind of requests and somehow must come to terms with it.

And that's the real kicker for me personally. Using sex as a way to progress your character, if pulled off correctly, is amazing to me. And that usually works better with female leads, in my opinion.
Your comment is really a relief for me
I try of the word that no woman like these game
or these game are not realistic...
no woman like this in real life
ahh...it's a porn game
it makes for feeling hot and erotic
and you prove that even a woman herself feeling hot with these plot
female can have fantasy in sex
it's not only for male's territory
 

NoxAeternae

Newbie
Jul 8, 2018
42
74
As a mostly straight male I highly prefer Female PC. It's not about immersion, there are countless things that immerse me in a game, the gender of the PC is not one of them. I think it's mostly about what I care for. I find it very difficult to care for a Male PC. Like why would I care if this dude does this, or has sex with that girl. It also doesn't help that most Male MC's are either horrible douches who cannot think about anything other than sex. But with an attractive Female PC, it's much easier for me to care about their story, to learn about her personality and to mold her character and journey according to my own values (which is why I love meaningful choices in games). Although this doesn't mean I care for any Female PC, I also find it hard to care for a stupid, uninteresting or douchy character regardless of their sex, sexuality or gender.
 

tsuchinokoreal

New Member
May 4, 2020
12
21
I am a straight male and I only play games with female MCs. For me, porn is a third-person experience where I view the scenes as an outsider rather than a role-playing experience where I insert as a specific character. I like most of the dialogue and thoughts of both the men and the women involved to be left to my imagination, as that leads to a greater variety of experiences if you will. Like the person above me I don't care about male MCs in porn as characters or males in porn in general. For me, men in porn are just walking cocks who may or may not fuck the female MC who is more interesting with good characterization.

Also, do people still do that "oh if you like female MCs you are gay or secretly want to be a woman" bullshit? That's so insecure lol
 

ChaosOpen

Well-Known Member
Game Developer
Sep 26, 2019
1,013
2,128
I am a straight male and I only play games with female MCs. For me, porn is a third-person experience where I view the scenes as an outsider rather than a role-playing experience where I insert as a specific character. I like most of the dialogue and thoughts of both the men and the women involved to be left to my imagination, as that leads to a greater variety of experiences if you will. Like the person above me I don't care about male MCs in porn as characters or males in porn in general. For me, men in porn are just walking cocks who may or may not fuck the female MC who is more interesting with good characterization.

Also, do people still do that "oh if you like female MCs you are gay or secretly want to be a woman" bullshit? That's so insecure lol
I know quite a few people who want nothing to do with Fate/stay Night due to the Chest Worms used on Sakura. They aren't afraid of them or fear that if reading it they would get devoured by bugs, it just grossed them out and they didn't want to read any more. Personally I don't like fat to see those ugly fat guys having sex, I have no fear of them, but watching Bubba-Earl the truck driver get his freak on just doesn't appeal to me.
 

d1Polterghost

Member
Jul 22, 2017
322
488
Personally I don't like fat to see those ugly fat guys having sex, I have no fear of them, but watching Bubba-Earl the truck driver get his freak on doesn't appeal to me.
True. You can call yourself straight but in the end most straight dudes would rather watch an attractive guy doing the thing.

Also, do people still do that "oh if you like female MCs you are gay or secretly want to be a woman" bullshit? That's so insecure lol
This entirely depends on the type of a game. I cant play an RPG as a woman protagonist, especially if there is a romance involved. Im not gonna romance with dudes because Im not a trap (and traps are gay) and Im not gonna romance with chicks because Im not that interested in lesbian relationships, sex sure but not much beside that.
 

Karnon254332

Newbie
Feb 20, 2019
92
108
I would play as females in non-porn games, but a game that contains content I masturbate to by empathizing with the MC? I normally don't choose to play as a female in adult games because it's uncomfortable for me. I know they exist, but I don't think I'm part of their demographic.

This is Karnon, a self-righteous fapper, signing off.
 

Zippity

Well-Known Member
Respected User
Nov 16, 2017
1,393
2,662
Here is my problem with games with female protagonist. Whenever I play as a woman I try to protect her, do not let any sex scene even to happen, especially those forced ones. This makes the whole experience pointless and is turning me off. Its like a fathers instinct is kicking in. Also a game in which a woman likes to fuck with different men feels like a game for women. Because of all that Im skipping every game with 'female protagonist' tag (which is a lot I noticed).
What are your thoughts on games like this? How do you enjoy them?
Is it just me or has the subject matter been popping into the top of the thread list quite a bit this past week? I feel like I've been conversing in some way shape or form about the topic of Female Protagonists in erotic VN/Games all week long... Hehe.. In any case...

The trouble I see, and this is a personal feeling (that I'm sure lots of other folks out there also agree with), is that most Female Protagonist based erotic VN/Games treat the female in a stereotyped manner... Usually in the form of being a victim of others, or being corrupted against her will, or having no other choice but to become subservient to some high powered pervert male/female, and the list goes on... It is EXTREMELY, rare to find a Female Protagonist in one of these things, where she is being handled in the way a normal woman, straight/lesbian/bi, would behave or allow herself to be treated... Most are not even treated in the same way many male protagonists are used either, being the ones driving the story, captains of their own destiny, influencing others rather then allowing ones self to be influenced, sticking up for themselves, and so on and so forth...

Sometimes they are straight forward victims out the gate, or perhaps under the ploy of being an open world/freedom of choice VN/Game, yet they eventually become victims of circumstance and/or others perversions... I've seen many various combinations...

This is where I run into problems with 9 out of 10 Female Protagonist based erotic VN/Games out there... Add to all that, female protagonists are already a rarity in the first place... Let alone done right, when attempts are made to do them right in the first place...

When I see all these female protagonist VN/Game where she is either constantly being treated as a victim, or is the one becoming corrupt, or the target of constant outside corruption, and so forth, it's no wonder so many folks are turned off by a female protagonist... When the pickin's are so slim...

There have only been a few occasions where I've run into a Female Protagonist based erotic VN/Game that I felt like it was either being done right and/or I was really enjoying reading/playing it... I would really like to see more available choices, but it is what it is...

Zip
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sphere42

d1Polterghost

Member
Jul 22, 2017
322
488
Is it just me or has the subject matter been popping into the top of the thread list quite a bit this past week? I feel like I've been conversing in some way shape or form about the topic of Female Protagonists in erotic VN/Games all week long... Hehe.. In any case...

The trouble I see, and this is a personal feeling (that I'm sure lots of other folks out there also agree with), is that most Female Protagonist based erotic VN/Games treat the female in a stereotyped manner... Usually in the form of being a victim of others, or being corrupted against her will, or having no other choice but to become subservient to some high powered pervert male/female, and the list goes on... It is EXTREMELY, rare to find a Female Protagonist in one of these things, where she is being handled in the way a normal woman, straight/lesbian/bi, would behave or allow herself to be treated... Most are not even treated in the same way many male protagonists are used either, being the ones driving the story, captains of their own destiny, influencing others rather then allowing ones self to be influenced, sticking up for themselves, and so on and so forth...

Sometimes they are straight forward victims out the gate, or perhaps under the ploy of being an open world/freedom of choice VN/Game, yet they eventually become victims of circumstance and/or others perversions... I've seen many various combinations...

This is where I run into problems with 9 out of 10 Female Protagonist based erotic VN/Games out there... Add to all that, female protagonists are already a rarity in the first place... Let alone done right, when attempts are made to do them right in the first place...

When I see all these female protagonist VN/Game where she is either constantly being treated as a victim, or is the one becoming corrupt, or the target of constant outside corruption, and so forth, it's no wonder so many folks are turned off by a female protagonist... When the pickin's are so slim...

There have only been a few occasions where I've run into a Female Protagonist based erotic VN/Game that I felt like it was either being done right and/or I was really enjoying reading/playing it... I would really like to see more available choices, but it is what it is...

Zip
All that is true but when you are allowed to pick and choose, a game essentialy transforms into a dating sim, which brings me to a question: why a straight dude would want to flirt with other dudes, even if it involves a hetero relationship? Is this like a hidden 'I want to be a father' desire and trying to pick best man for your "daughter"? Or maybe Im reaching too much and its like browsing porn, you already have your best girl now we need a good guy to fuck her?
 

Iramis

Member
Dec 3, 2018
103
185
...why a straight dude would want to flirt with other dudes, even if it involves a hetero relationship?...
The reason you're having trouble understanding is because you're taking how you view things and projecting onto others, expecting that everyone is the same way. Different people engage with games (and media in general) differently, some people self insert, some don't, some only do it in specific cases etc. So basically just accept the fact that some people think differently and you may not get it. For example I don't get why many people here have such visceral dislike of seeing other guys/dicks in their games, even if it's in a positive light. Before coming here I just assumed most people like seeing MMF threesomes, group sex, orgies etc, over normal vanilla stuff.

So for the question you asked, for me personally it's not about putting myself in any kind of roles, I'm only concerned with what is going on in the story/game. I can relate with the female protagonist, like them, care for them etc, but that's because most of the time in a FP game the main character is usually the best character, with more thought given to their story, personality and development because we spend most time with them. It's not about role playing or what I would do, it's about what I want the character to do. Also when I play a game I want to see everything it has to offer whether I like it or not, if I quit a game it's rarely because of a fetish or scene, it's mostly because I get annoyed with the writing. So I'm not flirting with a guy, I'm watching a girl flirt with a guy, she could flirt with two guys at the same time, have a threesome, and those could stop in the middle and start fucking each other and I won't mind because I don't care about those things, I'll probably be amused and move on.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dexter111

Zippity

Well-Known Member
Respected User
Nov 16, 2017
1,393
2,662
All that is true but when you are allowed to pick and choose, a game essentialy transforms into a dating sim, which brings me to a question: why a straight dude would want to flirt with other dudes, even if it involves a hetero relationship? Is this like a hidden 'I want to be a father' desire and trying to pick best man for your "daughter"? Or maybe Im reaching too much and its like browsing porn, you already have your best girl now we need a good guy to fuck her?
That isn't necessarily true, as most well done Female Protagonist VN/Games I've seen (amongst the sea of poorly designed and/or stereotyped ones) are in no way Dating Sims... They usually involve well told stories about a woman's life and the varying relationships she may be interested in or working on... Perhaps some folks just can't read stories without the need to insert themselves into the mindset of the main characters, so they can not read stories as an outside observer rather then immersing themselves into the main character... I sometimes immerse myself into a main character, and sometimes I do not... It's a choice and a feeling you get as you read a given story... Do you relate to some of the main characters plight, and perhaps feel more connected to the character... Or perhaps you do not relate at all, but can observe what the character goes through and empathize with their struggles and thoughts without necessarily feeling like it's you in the story...

When I watch a movie about a woman's story, I don't necessarily insert myself into that character, but I can surely empathize and become engrossed in her story, if it is being told well... So why couldn't I do the same when reading a book, or playing a story based VN/Game?

Everyone is different, and what everyone wants out of these erotic VN/Games is equally different... If you do not feel comfortable reading or playing a VN/Game with a female protagonist due to varying reasons, that is fine... No one will fault you for it, and it should be the same for folks who have no issues reading and playing a VN/Game with a female protagonist... And the reasons some folks may not mind reading/playing a VN/Game with a female protagonist will vary from person to person... There is no one answer as to why... Everyone is complex...

Zip
 
  • Like
Reactions: Iramis

d1Polterghost

Member
Jul 22, 2017
322
488
When I watch a movie about a woman's story, I don't necessarily insert myself into that character, but I can surely empathize and become engrossed in her story, if it is being told well... So why couldn't I do the same when reading a book, or playing a story based VN/Game?
I dont do that either but instead I want to protect her. I dont want some random dudes and monsters to exploit her. Maybe its just my loneliness talking. If I could put myself into a game with female protagonist I would flirt with myself and no one else and be fine with it.
When I played Tomb Raider reboot for the first time I put a jacket on Lara to protect her form the elements, like, who does that? On the other hand when I play Skyrim as a dude I let my female companion run around in a bikini during a blizzard.
 

Deleted member 440241

Active Member
Feb 14, 2018
755
1,621
Most of the ones I've come across are rather poorly written. They typically involve some clueless woman getting raped by every man she meets and just accepting it when they tell her that her loving husband will divorce her if he finds out. I'd really like to see more games like Village of Nightmare and Succulence.

I dont do that either but instead I want to protect her. I dont want some random dudes and monsters to exploit her. Maybe its just my loneliness talking. If I could put myself into a game with female protagonist I would flirt with myself and no one else and be fine with it.
When I played Tomb Raider reboot for the first time I put a jacket on Lara to protect her form the elements, like, who does that? On the other hand when I play Skyrim as a dude I let my female companion run around in a bikini during a blizzard.
I've seen enough comments like this on the thread I'm starting to wonder if I'm weird for not trying to protect video game characters I'm playing. I made a nudist brawler in Skyrim just so I could see my female character run around naked... and because no equipment means more space for loot. She'll be plundering all the booty.
 

EroticMK95

Newbie
May 11, 2019
74
151
I wish there was more of them but most of them aren't great but one of that I really like is Good Girl Gone Bad. The main issue is that most of the games with female protagonist are poorly written, poorly designed or simply just not well put together.
 

khumak

Engaged Member
Oct 2, 2017
3,548
3,580
I can enjoy female protagonist games, although I definitely prefer that the main character be male. I'm one of those people who tends to imagine myself as the main character when possible and I just can't do that if the main character is female.

My only other issue with female protagonist games is that they almost never give you any reason to think of the main character as anything but a total cumslut. If she has a husband or boyfriend he's almost always either a complete loser or a total asshole so of course you're going to cheat on him.

Where are the games that portray the husband or BF as either a good guy or at the very least an average guy instead of pond scum? Where are the games that reward the player for playing the wife as the "girl next door" type of woman instead of a street walker?

From what I've seen if you play a female protagonist game as a "good girl" you basically skip all of the content. So there's no reason to play them as anything but a cumslut.
 

Someone

Active Member
Jun 3, 2017
919
1,077
I kinda like playing as a female in RPGM games. I'm a detached player. I don't see "myself" as the player character.
I still have some problem with game over rape. As i always say: "porn is supposed to be my reward, not my punishment". And look like the great majority of devs can't find other ways for the heroine to have sex aside rape, blackmail, brainwashing, bestiality, and so on... and this is quite annoying.
Plus if a play as a female i don't mind gangbang, prostitution, and other stuff involving multiple partners. While if i play as a male harem protagonist all the girls must belong to my character alone and behave.
Not as much in first person games like visual novels. I guess that experiencing the situation directly from the main character point of view make me feel the immersion a little bit. Still i don't hate it. The "umichan" games made by Vortex00 are some of my favorites.

TL;DR
Is fun sluttying around as a girl. But damn, don't make it depressing every single time. Let me play a nympho more often.
 

Zippity

Well-Known Member
Respected User
Nov 16, 2017
1,393
2,662
I can enjoy female protagonist games, although I definitely prefer that the main character be male. I'm one of those people who tends to imagine myself as the main character when possible and I just can't do that if the main character is female.

My only other issue with female protagonist games is that they almost never give you any reason to think of the main character as anything but a total cumslut. If she has a husband or boyfriend he's almost always either a complete loser or a total asshole so of course you're going to cheat on him.

Where are the games that portray the husband or BF as either a good guy or at the very least an average guy instead of pond scum? Where are the games that reward the player for playing the wife as the "girl next door" type of woman instead of a street walker?

From what I've seen if you play a female protagonist game as a "good girl" you basically skip all of the content. So there's no reason to play them as anything but a cumslut.
It's the problem we see with the new Female Protagonist based erotic VN/Games in the first place... They are either the victims of circumstance, or treated as the one becoming corrupted by everything around her, or is treated like a ditz who can only ever be taken advantage of, and the list goes on... It is rare, to find a Female Protagonist treated like a normal female actually is, or treated in the same way most male protagonists are treated in these things... I've tried most I run into, and I have come across some decent ones, but they are diamonds in the ruff, in a sea of poorly crafted female protagonist VN/Games...

There are also a lot of copy cat games, where as you said, the female protagonist is either married to or begins in a relationship with either a schmuck, a womanizer, and/or a very poorly crafted and weak male/female character in general... I think it's probably due to a lack of imagination, and/or developers wanting to design their own "take" on an already used story mechanic/trope... Either to jump on someone else's money train or they just lack the ability to make something more unique...

Good Girl Gone Bad was unique in that you had the options to go either route... Become a trashy sex object, have a semi-normal life, or be a mix match... Heck you could even dive into the trashy stuff, then reverse tracks and become less trashy... But that game was also highly complex and very unique, as most VN/Games with a female protagonist go one way only, and that is directly to varying levels of trash/corruption...

Blooming Love was one of the better VN/Games with a female protagonist, as it felt more natural... And she was not a victim or a target of corruption, etc... Even though it was kind of an incest story...

There are a few other good ones, but I just can't think of their names right now...

For me, beyond the realistic portrayals of a female as the protagonist, I'ld also like to see the Female Protagonists taking on a role more in tune with how most male protagonists are treated... The one in charge of their own destinies, not being the target of corruption and/or bad circumstances, but the one in charge making the decisions to go after others or play the actual lead in the story... Not the prey every time, but perhaps the predator, without necessarily becoming a slut in the process... I hope what I'm saying is making sense...

I dont do that either but instead I want to protect her. I dont want some random dudes and monsters to exploit her. Maybe its just my loneliness talking. If I could put myself into a game with female protagonist I would flirt with myself and no one else and be fine with it.
When I played Tomb Raider reboot for the first time I put a jacket on Lara to protect her form the elements, like, who does that? On the other hand when I play Skyrim as a dude I let my female companion run around in a bikini during a blizzard.
I usually find that if the story is being told well, and I'm feeling that immersion of myself into the story in some way, then yes I also feel a bit protective of the various characters that I feel are actual or possible relationship characters for the protagonist... I don't want them to come to harm, or become victims of others, etc... In the same way I might feel if I was in a real relationship with someone, or was in some sort of mutual attraction with...

As to the whole female character in normal games, 9 times out of 10 I tend to play a female character in MMORPG's usually because the models are better made and the costume options are usually better... I don't always play female characters, it just depends on the game. character class, costume options, and so on... It was just something I got used to doing, when I first got into MMORPG's in general... I had joined a Super Group in City of Heroes that was an all female toon SG, and played with them for years... It kind of just went from there... But in other games, like Minecraft, first person shooters, survival MMO's, and so on I tend to stick with my own gender a majority of the time... Just depends on my mood at the time if I had to guess...

Zip
 
Last edited: