Could be fun,
but there should be some rules then.
Like what games can participate
Games that are done or games that started in 2017.
Some games (see popular threads) do have a lot of fans, but also a lot of haters.
Could be that a big amount of players like game A, but it's actually at the same time
hated be even a bigger amount.
Though some simple polls with a clean layout after a preselection could result in some nice GOTY-awards.